¹« ·¨ ÆÀ ÂÛ |
ΩԸ¹«Æ½Èç´óË®¹ö¹ö£¬Ê¹¹«ÒåÈ罺ÓÌÏÌÏ£¡ |
µ± ´ú ÃÀ ¹ú ×Ô È» ·¨ Àí ÂÛ ×ß ÊÆ
Kenneth Einar HimmaÖø ÐìˬÒë
Õª Òª£º×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ¿É´ÓµÀµÂµÄ¡¢·¨Âɵĵȶà¸ö½Ç¶È¼ÓÒÔ̽ÌÖ¡£·²Ö÷ÕÅ·¨Ö®Îª¡°·¨¡±±ØµÃÂú×ãµÀµÂÒªÇ󣬻òÕß˵£¬·¨×îÖØÒªµÄÌØÕ÷Ö®Ò»ÄË·¨¾ß±¸µÄµÀµÂÐÔÕâÒ»¹Ûµã£¬¾ùÊô¡°½»µþÀíÂÛ¡±¡£È»£¬½»µþÀíÂÛÓë¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧÏ໥½»²æ¡¢ÉøÍ¸£¬ÑÜÉú³ö¶àÖÖ²»Í¬µÄ±í´ï·½Ê½¡£±¾ÎÄÔÚ´Ë»ù´¡ÉÏ£¬¶Ôµ±´úÃÀ¹ú×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂ۵Ļù±¾×ßÏòºÍÁ÷ÅɽøÐÐÁËÒ»·¬±È½ÏÏ꾡µÄ¿¼²é£¬ÆäÖУ¬ÓÈÒÔ·ÆÄá˹¡¢¸»Àպ͵ÂÎÖ½ðµÈÈ˵ÄÀíÂÛÎªÖØ¡£
¹Ø¼ü´Ê£º×ÔÈ»·¨£»½»µþÂÛ£»¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧ£»ÐÂ×ÔÈ»·¨Ö÷Ò壻³ÌÐò×ÔÈ»·¨£»¡°µÚÈýÀíÂÛ¡±
¢ñ.×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛµÄÁ½´ó´«Í³
¡°×ÔÈ»·¨¡±ÕâÒ»·¶³ëÏ൱º¬»ì£¬Ëü¼ÈÊÇÒ»ÖÖµÀµÂÀíÂÛ£¬Í¬Ê±Ò²ÊÇÒ»ÖÖ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ¡ª¡ª¾¡¹Ü´Ë¶þÖÖÀíÂ۵ĺËÐÄÄÚÈÝÔÚÂß¼ÉÏÊÇÏ໥¶ÀÁ¢µÄ¡£´Ó×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛ¿´£¬Ö§ÅäÈËÀàÐÐΪµÄµÀµÂ±ê×¼ÔÚijÖ̶ֳÈÉÏÊǿ͹۵ØÀ´Ô´ÓÚÈ˵ı¾ÐԵģ»¶ø¾Í×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ¶øÑÔ£¬Ò»Ð©(ʵÔÚ·¨µÄ)·¨Âɹ淶×îÆðÂëµÄȨÍþÐÔÔòÊÇ»ùÓÚ´¦ÀíÕâЩ¹æ·¶µÄµÀµÂÓų¤µÄÖÖÖÖ¿¼ÂÇ¡£×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛÓÐÐí¶àÁ÷ÅÉ£¬¸ù¾ÝµÀµÂÔÚ¾ö¶¨·¨ÂɹæÔòȨÍþÐÔʱËùÆðµÄ×÷Óò»Í¬¶ø±Ë´ËÏàÇø±ð¡£
Ê×ÏÈ£¬ÎÒÃÇÓбØÒªÇø·ÖËùν×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛµÄÁ½´óÖÖÀ࣬¼´ÈçǰËùÊöµÄ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛºÍ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ¡£ÓйØ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛ´óÖ¿ÉÒÔ×÷ÈçϽ綨£ºµÚÒ»£¬µÀµÂÖ÷ÕÅÔÚijÖÖÒâÒåÉϱ»ÊÓΪһÖֿ͹۱ê×¼£¬Òò¶øËüÃÇ¿ÉÒÔ³ÉÎªÕæÊµ¼ÛÖµµÄÔØÌ壻»»¾ä»°½²£¬ÕâЩµÀµÂÒªÇó±¾Éí¼´ÊÇÒ»Öֿ͹۵ÄÕæ»ò¼ÙµÄÅжϡ£¾¡¹ÜµÀµÂ¿Í¹ÛÖ÷ÒåÓÐʱ¿ÉµÈͬÓÚµÀµÂʵÔÚÂÛ£¨²Î¼ûMoore 1992£¬190£º¡°ÈκεÀµÂÖ÷ÕŵÄÕæÚж¼ÔÚÓÚËüÊÇÒ»ÖÖ¶ÀÁ¢ÓÚÈ˵ÄÒâʶ¡¢¶ÀÁ¢ÓÚ´«Í³¹ßÀýµÄµÀµÂÏÖʵ¡£¡±£©£»È»£¬Á½ÖÖÀíÂÛÖ®¼äµÄ¹ØÏµÈÔÊÇÓдý¶¨Â۵ġ£±ÈÈ磬Âõ¿ÆµÂ£¨Geoffrey Sayre£McCord£¬1988£©¼´ÈÏΪ£ºµÀµÂ¿Í¹ÛÖ÷ÒåÄ˵ÀµÂʵÔÚÂÛµÄÒ»ÖÖ£¬µ«¾ø·ÇΨһÐÎʽ¡£°´Âõ¿ÆµÂµÄ¹Ûµã£¬µÀµÂÖ÷¹ÛÖ÷ÒåºÍ×¼µÀµÂÖ÷¹ÛÖ÷Ò壨intersubjectivism£©¾ùÊôµÀµÂʵÔÚÂÛµÄÐÎʽ¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬ÑϸñµØËµ£¬×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛ¼´±»ÏÞ¶¨ÔÚµÀµÂ±ê×¼µÄ¿Í¹ÛÐÔÖ®ÖС£
¹¹³É×ÔÈ»·¨µÀµÂÀíÂ۵ĵڶþ¸öÃüÌâ¼´ÊÇÐû³Æ£¬ÖÖÖÖµÀµÂ±ê×¼ÔÚij¸ö³Ì¶ÈÉÏÀ´×ÔÓÚ¡¢»ò¼Ù¶¨ÆäÀ´×ÔÓÚÊÀ½ç±¾Ô´ºÍÈËÀà±¾ÐÔ¡£Ê¥?ÍÐÂí˹?°¢¿üÄǾÍÔøÒÔÈ˵ÄÀíÐÔÀ´½ç˵×ÔÈ»·¨£º¡°ÀíÐÔÄËÈËÀàÐÐΪµÄ±ê³ß£¬ÕâÊÇÈËÀàÐÐΪµÄµÚÒ»ÒªÔò¡£¡±£¨Aquinas£¬ST ¢ñ£¢ò£¬Q.90£¬A.I.£©Ò»°ã¶øÑÔ£¬¼ÈÈ»ÈËÀàÊÇÌìÉúµÄÀíÐÔ¶¯ÎÄÇô£¬ËûÃÇ×ñ´ÓÀíÐÔÐÐÊÂÔÚµÀµÂÉÏÒà¾ÍÊÇ×ÔÈ»¶øÈ»µÄÁË¡£»ùÓÚ´Ë£¬°¢¿üÄÇ´ÓÈËÀàµÄ±¾ÐÔÖÐÍÆÑܳö×ÔÈ»·¨¡£
µ«ÊÇ£¬ÁíÒ»ÖÖ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛÐèÒª½â¾öµÄÔòÊÇÀåÇåµÀµÂÓë·¨ÂÉÖ®¼äµÄ¹ØÏµ¡£ÔÚ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ¿´À´£¬·¨ÂɵÄÒâͼÓëµÀµÂµÄÖ÷Õż䲢ÎÞ¶àÉÙÃ÷ÏÔ·ÖÒ°¡£ËäÈ»×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ´æÔÚÖî¶àÁ÷ÅÉ£¬µ«ËùÓÐÔÞͬÕâÒ»ÀíÂÛµÄѧÕß¶¼³ÐÈÏ£ºÖÁÉÙÓв¿·Ö·¨ÂÉ£¬ËüÃǵġ°È¨Íþ¡±Êǽ¨Á¢ÔÚÆäÓëµÀµÂ±ê×¼µÄÂß¼ÁªÏµÉÏ£¬¶ø·ÇÈ¡¾öÓÚijЩԶ¹Åʱ´úÐγɵĹßÀý£¨convention£©¡£ÉõÖÁ£¬ÔÚÓеÄÇé¿öÏ£¬µ±³õÈËÃDz¢Î´ÈÏ¿ÉijһµÀµÂÓų¤Îª·¨ÂÉÕýµ±ÐÔµÄ×¼¾Ý£¬ÕâЩ·¨ÂɹæÔòÒ²»áÒòΪÆäËù¾ßÓеĵÀµÂÄÚÈݶøÉÏÉýΪһÖÖȨÍþ¡£ÎÒÃǹÃÇÒ½«ÕâÖÖ·¨ÂÉÓëµÀµÂÏ໥½»´íµÄÀíÂÛ³ÆÎª½»µþÂÛ£¨Overlap Thesis£©¡£[1]
ÑϸñµØ½²£¬ËäÈ»ÓйØ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛÓë·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛÔÚÂß¼ÉÏÊÇÏ໥¶ÀÁ¢µÄ£»µ«¾Í¾Ñé¶øÂÛ£¬³ÖǰһÀíÂÛµÄѧÕß´ó¶àÒ²ÊÇ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÂÛÕß¡£·´Ö®£¬·ñ¶¨×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÂÛ²¢²»Òâζ×ÅÒò´Ë¾Í·´¶Ô×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛ¡£Æ©È磬Լº²¡¤°Â˹¶¡£¨John Austin£©¡ª¡ªÔçÆÚ×îÓÐÓ°ÏìµÄʵ֤·¨Ñ§¼Ò¡ª¡ªËû¾Í²»ÔÞͬËùνµÄ½»µþÂÛ£¬µ«Æä¹ÛµãÈ´½Ó½üÓÚ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛ¡£
ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬°Â˹¶¡Ì¹ÂʵØÈÏΪһÖÖ·¨Âɹ淶µÄÕýµ±ÐÔûÓбØÒª·ÇÈ¡¾öÓÚÆäÄÚÈݵĵÀµÂÐÔ²»¿É¡£µ«ÊÇ£¬µ±ËûÔھܾø½»µþÀíÂÛµÄͬʱ£¬ËûÓֺܴó³Ì¶ÈµØ½ÓÊÜÁË×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ¿Í¹ÛµÀµÂÀíÂÛ¡ª¡ª°Â˹¶¡¼¸ºõÈ«Å̼̳ÐÁËÄÂÀÕ£¨J.S.Mill£©ºÍ±ßÇߣ¨Jeremy Bentham£©µÄ¹¦ÀûÖ÷Òå¡£ÖµµÃÒ»ÌáµÄÊÇ£¬¹¦ÀûÖ÷ÒåÕßÓÐʱҲ½«ËûÃǵÄÀíÂÛ¹éÒòÓÚÈËÐÔµÄÄ³Ð©ÌØÕ÷¡£ÕýÈç±ßÇßÔø¾Ð´µÀ£¬¡°ÀíÐÔ½«ÈËÀàÖÃÓÚÖÁ¸ßÎÞÉϵÄÁ½¸ö¾ýÖ÷¡ª¡ª±¯Óëϲ¡ª¡ªµÄͳÖÎ֮ϡ£ËüÄÜÖ¸ÒýÎÒÃÇʲôÊÇÓ¦¸Ã×öµÄ£¬Ê²Ã´Êǽ«Òª×öµÄ¡£¶ÔÓë´íµÄ±ê³ß¡¢ÒòÓë¹ûµÄËøÁ´¶¼±»½ô½ôµØÏµÓÚËûÃǵÄÍõ×ù¡±£¨Bentham 1948£¬1£©¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬¶Ô×ÔÈ»·¨µÀµÂÀíÂÛµÄÈÏͬʵ¼ÊÉÏÓë¶Ô×ÔÈ»·¨·¨ÂÉÀíÂ۵ķñÈÏÏàµ÷ºÍÁË¡£
È»¶ø£¬·´¹ýÀ´½²£¬Ò»¸öÈË·ÅÆú×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛÈ´ÒÀÈ»¼á³Ö×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÂÛ£¬ÕâÖÖÇé¿öËäÈ»Ïʼû£¬µ¹Ò²²»ÊÇûÓС£±ÈÈç˵£¬Ëû¿ÉÒÔÈÏΪ·¨ÂɵĸÅÄîÐÔÌØÕ÷£¨conceptual point£©ÊÇÔÚ²¿·ÖµØ¸´ÖƵÀµÂµÄÒªÇó£»µ«Í¬Ê±ËûÒ²»á³ÖÒ»ÖÖÂ×ÀíÖ÷¹ÛÖ÷Ò壨»òÏà¶ÔÖ÷Ò壩µÄÁ¢³¡¡£¾ÍÎÒ¸öÈËµÄ¹Ûµã¶øÑÔ£¬·¨ÂɵÄÕâÖÖ¸ÅÄîÐÔÌØÕ÷Ö¼ÔÚÇ¿»¯ÈçϹÛÄ¼´·¨ÂɿɻùÓÚÈËÃǵĺÏÒâ¶ø»ñµÃµÀµÂÉϵÄÕýµ±ÐÔ¡£ÓÉÊÇ£¬×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ±ãºÍ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÀµÂÀíÂÛÏà»¥Çø±ð¶ø¸÷×Ô¶ÀÁ¢¡£±¾ÎÄÓàÏÂµÄÆª·ùÄâ¶Ô×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ½øÐÐרÃÅÌÖÂÛ¡£
¢ò.¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ
¢ò.1 ¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧ[2] ¼òÊö
´«Í³ÉÏ£¬¸ÅÄîÐÔ£¨»ò·ÖÎöÐÔ£©·¨ÕÜѧµÄÊ×ҪĿ±êÔÚÓÚÌṩһÌ×½âÊÍÀíÂÛÒÔ½«·¨ÂɹæÔò´ÓÆäËü¹æÔòÌåϵ£¨ÖîÈçÂ×Àí¹æÔò£©ÖаþÀë³öÀ´¡£³ÏÈç°Â˹¶¡ËùÑÔ£¬¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧÊÇÔÚѰÕÒ¡°ÄÇЩ´æÔÚÓÚËùÓз¨ÂÉÖеÄÒªËØºÍÌØÕ÷¡±£¨Austin 1995£¬11£©¡£»»¾ä»°Ëµ£¬¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧµÄÈÎÎñÖ¼ÔÚÿһ¿ÉÄܵÄÁìÓòÄÚÎªÇø±ð·¨Óë·Ç·¨¸ø³öһϵÁбØÒª¶ø³ä·ÖµÄÌõ¼þÒÔÖ¤Ã÷·¨µÄ´æÔÚ¡£
¼ÈÈ»ÕâÒ»ÈÎÎñͨ³£±»½âÊÍΪһÖÖ·ÖÎö·¨ºÍ·¨ÂÉÌåϵµÄ³¢ÊÔ£¬ÄÇô£¬ÔÚ¸ÅÄîÐÔ·ÖÎöµÄ¼ÛÖµÓëÌØÕ÷·½Ãæ³öÏÖһЩ»ìÏýÒ²ÊǺÜ×ÔÈ»µÄÁË¡£²¼À×¶÷¡¤À³ÌØ£¨Brian Leiter£¬1998£©Ö¸³ö£¬¾ø´ó¶àÊýÕÜѧÃÅÀà¶¼²ÉȡһÖÖ×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåµÄ×÷·¨£¬½«¿ÆÑ§µÄ·½·¨Ó빤¾ßºÏ¶øÎªÒ»£»¶øºÜÉÙÓÐÕÜѧѧ¿ÆÏñ·¨ÕÜѧ£¨Ö¸·ÖÎö·¨ÕÜѧ¡ª¡ªÒëÕß×¢£©Ò»Ñù£¬°Ñ¸ÅÄîÐÔ·ÖÎö×÷ΪÆäÑо¿Öص㡣²¼À×¶÷¡¤±Ï¿Ë˹£¨Brian Bix£¬1995£©¸ø³öÁ˽øÐиÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧÑо¿µÄһЩ²»Í¬Ä¿µÄ£º¢ÅÑØÏ®ÓïÒå·ÖÎöµÄ·½·¨£»¢ÆÏÞ¶¨ÒâÒ壻¢ÇÖ¸Ã÷ijÀàÑо¿¶ÔÏóµÄÖØµãºÍ»ù´¡£»¢ÈΪ¸ÅÄîÊÀ½ç½¨Á¢Ò»ÌׯÀ¼ÛÌåϵ¡£±Ï¿Ë˹ÔÚ·¨Ñ§Ñо¿ÖвÉÓõĸÅÄî·ÖÎöÖ÷񻃾¼°¢ÇºÍ¢È¡£
ÎÞÂÛÈçºÎ£¬·¨ÂɵĸÅÄî·ÖÎö¶¼ÔÚÏÖ´ú·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛÖÐÕ¼ÓÐÖØÒªµÄһϯ֮µØ¡£³¤ÆÚÒÔÀ´£¬·¨µÄ¸ÅÄîÐÔÀíÂÛµÄÒ»¸öÏÔÖøÌØÕ÷ÌåÏÖÔÚËü¶Ô½»µþÀíÂÛµÄ̬¶ÈÉÏ¡£¾ÝÓÚ´Ë£¬Ëü¿É·ÖΪÁ½´óÀà±ð£ºÆäÒ»£¬ÇãÏòÓÚ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛÒò¶øÈÏͬ·¨ÓëµÀµÂÖ®¼ä´æÔÚ¸ÅÄîÐÔÁªÏµ£»Æä¶þ£¬ÇãÏòÓÚ·¨ÂÉʵ֤Ö÷Òå¼Ì¶ø·ñ¶¨ÕâÒ»ÁªÏµ¡£
¢ò.2¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧÊÓ½ÇϵĹŵä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ
ÎÞÂÛºÎÖÖ×ÔÈ»·¨¹ÛÄî¶¼ÔÞͬ½»µþÂÛ£¬¼´ËüÃǶ¼Ç¿µ÷·¨ÓëµÀµÂÖ®¼ä´æÔÚ×ÅijÖÖ·ÇÐÎʽÉϵģ¨non£conventional£©ÁªÏµ¡£¸ù¾ÝÕâÖֹ۵㣬˳Àí³ÉÕµıãÊÇ£¬À뿪Á˵ÀµÂÂÉÁîµÄ²é¿¼¾ÍÎÞ·¨ÍêÈ«ÇåÎúµØ²ûÃ÷·¨ÂɵĹæÔò¡£¾¡¹Ü½»µþÂÛ²¢·Çº¬ºý²»Ç壬µ«ËüÈÔÓжàÖÖ²»Í¬µÄ±íÊö·½Ê½¡£
½»µþÀíÂÛÖÐ×îÓмÛÖµµÄ²¿·Ö¹¹³ÉÁ˰¢¿üÄÇ£¨Aquinas£©ºÍ²¼À³¿Ë¶Ù£¨Blackstone£©¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂ۵Ļùʯ¡£°¢¿üÄǽ«·¨ÂÉ·ÖΪÈçÏÂËÄÖÖ£º¢ÅÓÀºã·¨£¨eternal law£©£»¢Æ×ÔÈ»·¨£¨natural law£©£»¢ÇÈË·¨£¨human law£©ºÍ¢ÈÉñ·¨£¨divine law£©¡£ÓÀºã·¨ÊÇÓÉÄÇЩ֧ÅäÓÀºãÓîÖæµÄ¹æÂÉËù×é³É£»ÈçËÕæ©¡¤µÏĪ¿Ë£¨Susan Dimok£¬1999£¬22£©Ëù˵£¬ÓÀºã·¨ÄËÊÇ¡°ËùÓÐͳϽÓîÖæÍòÎïµÄ¿ÆÑ§¹æÂÉ£¨°üÀ¨ÎïÀí£¬»¯Ñ§£¬ÉúÎÐÄÀíѧµÈµÈ£©Ö®¼¯´ó³ÉÕß¡±¡£Éñ·¨ËùÉæ¼°µÄÔòÊÇÿһ¸ö¸öÌåµÄÈËÓûʵÏÖÓÀºã¾ÈÊê¶ø±ØÐëÂļùµÄ½äÌõ¡£µ±È»£¬Ò»¸öÈËÒ²²»Äܽöƾ×Ô¼ºµÄÀíÐÔÈ¥·¢ÏÖÉñ·¨£¬Éñ·¨½äÂɵġ°·¢ÏÖ¡±Ö»ÄÜͨ¹ýÉñÃØµÄÌìÆô£¨divine revelation£©¡£
×ÔÈ»·¨ÊôÓÚÓÀºã·¨ÖÐÖ§ÅäÈËÀàÐÐΪµÄÄÇÒ»²¿·Ö·¨Ôò£¬¶øÈ˵ÄÐÐΪÓÖÊÜ¿ØÓÚÀíÐÔºÍ×ÔÓÉÒâÖ¾¡£ÔÚ°¢¿üÄÇ¿´À´£¬×ÔÈ»·¨µÄµÚÒ»ÒªÒåÔÚÓÚ¶à¶àÉÙÉÙÏÔµÃÓе㺬ºýµÄÐÐÉÆ±Ü¶ñ¡£ÖµµÃÒ»ÌáµÄÊǰ¢¿üÄÇËù³ÖµÄ×ÔÈ»·¨µÀµÂÂÛ¡£ËûÈÏΪµÄÉÆ¶ñ±ê×¼¾ùÀ´×ÔÓÚÈËÀàµÄÀíÐÔ¡£ÉÆÓë¶ñÒ²Òò´ËÊǿ͹۵ĶøÇÒÊÇÆÕÊʵġ£
Óë´Ëͬʱ£¬°¢¿üÄÇÒ²ÊÇһλ×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨ÂÉÂÛÕß¡£ËûÈÏΪ£¬ÈË·¨£¨¼´ÓÉÈËÀàËù°ä²¼µÄ·¨£©½ö½öÖ»ÔÚÆäÄÚÈݺϺõ×ÔÈ»·¨ÒªÇóµÄÇé¿öϲÅÊÇÓÐЧµÄ¡£ËûÕâÑùдµÀ£¬¡°Ã¿Ò»ÌõÈËÀàµÄ·¨Âɶ¼ÒòΪÀ´×Ô×ÔÈ»·¨¶øÓµÓÐÁË·¨µÄÌØÐÔ¡£Ò»µ©ÈκÎÒ»Ìõ·¨ÂÉÆ«ÀëÁË×ÔÈ»µÄ·¨Ôò£¬Ëü¾Í²»ÔÙÊÇ·¨¶ø½ö½öÖ»ÊǶԷ¨µÄ±³ÅÑ¡£¡±£¨ST ¢ñ£¢ò£¬ Q.95£¬A.¢ò£©ÕâÑùµÄ»°£¬¼òÖ±¾ÍÊǰ¹Å˹¶¡£¨Augustine£©ÄÇÌõÖøÃûÂ۶ϵÄÒ»¸ö×¢½Å£¬¡°²»ÕýÒåµÄ·¨Âɸù±¾¾Í²»ÊÇ·¨ÂÉ¡£¡±µ±È»£¬Î¥±³×ÔÈ»·¨µÄ·¨¹æ²»¾ßÓз¨ÂÉЧÁ¦¡ª¡ªÕâÒ»¹ÛÄîͬÑùÒ²ÊǸÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂ۵ľµäÃüÌâ¡£ÍþÁ®¡¤²¼À³¿Ë¶Ù£¨William Blackstone£©ÊÇÕâÑù²ûÊöÕâÒ»ÃüÌâµÄ£¬¡°×ÔÈ»µÄ·¨Ôò£¬µÃ×ÔÉϵۣ¬ÀíËùµ±È»µØ½ÏÆäËüÈκι淶¸üΪÓÅÔ½¡£ËüµÄÔ¼Êø±é¼°Õû¸öÓîÖæ£¬ÎÞ´¦²»ÔÚ£¬ÎÞʱ²»ÓС£Ò»ÇÐÈËÀàµÄÁ¢·¨ÓëÖ®Ïà㣣¬ÔòÎÞÈκκϷ¨ÐÔ¿ÉÑÔ¡£²¢ÇÒ£¬ÈËÀàµÄÁ¢·¨ÕýÊÇ´ÓËüÃǵÄÔ´Í·£¨¼´×ÔÈ»·¨£©ÖзÖÏíÆäÈ«²¿µÄÁ¦Á¿ºÍȨÍþ¡±¡££¨1979£¬41£©ÔÚÕâÆªÎÄÕÂÖУ¬²¼À³¿Ë¶Ù»¹Ï꾡µØ²ûÃ÷Á˹¹³É¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛºËÐĵÄÁ½ÏîÔÔò£º¢ÅÓë×ÔÈ»·¨Ïà³åÍ»µÄ¹æÔò²»¾ßÓÐÕýµ±µÄºÏ·¨ÐÔ£»¢ÆËùÓÐÓÐЧµÄ·¨ÂÉ£¬ÆäÁ¦Á¿ÓëȨÍþÖ»ÄÜÀ´Ô´ÓÚ×ÔÈ»·¨¡£
ÐèÒªÖ¸³öµÄÊÇ£¬¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛͬÑùÒ²³ÐÈÏÈ˱¾ÉíÔÚÁ¢·¨¹ý³ÌÖÐËù·¢»ÓµÄÖØÒª×÷Óᣵ±¹Åµä×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåÕßËÆºõÔÚÔÞͬ·¨ÂÉÖÆ¶¨±ØÐë½áºÏËùÓеÀµÂÂÉÁîʱ£¬ËûÃDz¢Ã»ÓаµÊ¾·¨ÂɾͻáÒò´Ë±»ÖÚ¶àµÄµÀµÂÂÉÁîÏûºÄ´ù¾¡¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬¹Åµä×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåÕß²¢Ã»Óзñ¶¨ÈËÀàÔÚ´´ÖÆ·¨ÂɵĹý³ÌÖÐÈԿɱ£Áô×ã¹»µÄÅжÏÁ¦¡£ÎãÄþ˵£¬ËûÃǽö½öÊÇÐû³Æ£¬ÕâÖÖÅжÏÁ¦±ØÐëÒªÊܵÀµÂ½äÂɵÄÏÞÖÆ£ºÄÇЩÓÉÈËÀàËù°ä¶¨µÄ·¨ÂɹæÔòÖ»ÓÐÔÚ·ûºÏµÀµÂµÄǰÌáϲÅÊÇÓÐЧµÄ¡£
¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛµÄÅúÆÀ¼ÒÃdz£³£¶ÔÉÏÊö¹ÛµãÌá³ö¸÷ÖÖÒìÒé¡£Ê×ÏÈ£¬ÄÇЩ·´¶Ô°Â¹Å˹¶¡µÄ·¨Ñ§Õß»á˵£¬²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨ÂÉÊÂʵÉϱ»Ì«¹ýƵ·±µØÊµÐÐ×Å¡£°Â˹¶¡¾ÍÔøºÜר¶ÏµØÖ¸³ö£º
ËùνµÄ·²ÓëÉñ·¨Ïàì¶ÜµÄÈË·¨¾ùÎÞÔ¼ÊøÁ¦£¬»òÕß˵£¬¸ù±¾¾Í²»ÊÇ·¨¡ª¡ªÕâÒ»ÂÛ¶ÏʵÔÚÊÇÊ®×ãµÄÍýÓï¡£ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬ÄÇЩ×îа¶ñµÄ·¨ÂÉ£¬Ò²¾ÍÊÇ×îÓÐÎ¥ÉϵÛÖ¼ÒâµÄ·¨ÂÉ£¬¹ýÈ¥Ò»Ö±²¢ÇÒÏÖÔÚÈÔÈ»±»·¨Ôº×÷Ϊ·¨ÂÉÔÚÇ¿ÐÐʵʩ×Å¡£¼ÙÉèijһÐÐΪÊÇÎÞÉË´óÑÅ¡¢ÉõÖÁ¿Ï¶¨ÓÐÒæµÄ£¬È´±»¾ýÖ÷¶¨ÎªÐë´¦ÒÔ¼«Ð̵Ä×ï×´£»ÓÖ¼ÙÉèÎÒʵʩÁËÕâÒ»ÐÐΪ£¬ÎÞÒÉ£¬ÎÒ½«±»´þ²¶²¢Ðû²¼ÓÐ×ï¡£ÎÒµ±È»·´¶ÔÕâÒ»Åоö£¬ÒòΪËüÓÐã£ÓÚÉϵ۵ÄÂÉÁ¡ªÉϵÛÐû³ÆÈκÎÈËÀàÁ¢·¨Õß²»µÃ½ûÖ¹ÄÇЩ¡°È«ÎÞ×ï¶ñºó¹û¡±µÄÐÐΪ¡£È»¶ø£¬½á¾ÖÊÆ·¨Ôº½«ÅоöÎÒµÄÀíÓɲ»³ÉÁ¢²¢½«ÎÒÎʵõ£¬ÒÔÈ·±£±»ÎÒËùÇÖº¦µÄ·¨Âɵġ°ÓÐЧÐÔ¡±¡££¨Austin 1995£¬158£©
µ±È»£¬ÕýÈç²¼À×¶÷¡¤±Ï¿Ë˹£¨1999£©ËùÑÔ£¬ÕâÖÖÌÖÂÛ¶Ô°Â˹¶¡À´ËµÆäʵÆð²»Á˶à´ó×÷Óá£ÒòΪ·¨Ôº×ÜÄÜÕҵõ½ÀíÓÉȥʵʩһÖÖ°Â˹¶¡°´Æä¸öÈËÀí½âÈÏΪ²»¾ß±¸·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐԵ퍡£
ÁíÒ»¸ö¾³£±»Ìá¼°µÄÓÇÂÇ£¬±ãÊǸÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛÆÆ»µÁ˶Է¨ÂɽøÐеÀµÂÅúÅеĿÉÄÜÐÔ¡£ÓÉÓÚ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔµÄÒ»¸öÏȾöÌõ¼þÊDZØÐëÓë×ÔÈ»·¨±£³ÖÒ»Ö£»Òò´Ë£¬ËùÓÐÓÐЧµÄ·¨Âɶ¼³ÉÁ˵ÀµÂÐԵġ£ÒÀ´ËÀàÍÆ£¬Ò»Ìõ¹æ·¶µÄ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔ±ØÈ»µØÑݱäΪµÀµÂÕýÒå¡£¿¨ÀÕÂü£¨Jules Coleman£© ºÍÄ«·Æ£¨Jeffrey Murphy£©¶Ô´ËÆÀ¼ÛµÀ£º
ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬£¨¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ£©ÔÊÐíÎÒÃÇËùΪµÄÄÇÐ©ÖØÒªÊÂÏ±ÈÈ磬¶Ô·¨ÂɵĵÀµÂÆÀ¼Û»ò´Ó·¨ÂɽǶȾö¶¨ÎÒÃǵĵÀµÂÒåÎñ£©Ö»»áÒòΪµÀµÂÓë·¨ÂÉÖ®¼ä½çÏ޵ıÀËú¶ø±äµÃ¸ü¼ÓÀ§ÄÑ¡£¼ÙÈçÎÒÃÇÖ»ÊÇһζµØ´òËã´ÓµÀµÂµÄ¹ÛµãÈ¥¿¼ÂÇ·¨ÂÉÎÊÌ⣬¼ÙÈçÎÒÃÇÊÓ·¨Âɺ͵ÀµÂÖ®¼ä´æÔÚ±¾ÖÊÉϵÄijÖ̶ֳÈÁªÏµ£¬ÕâÑù×öµÄ½á¹ûÖ»ÄÜʹ·¨Âɱ¾Éí¸ü¼Ó»Þ°µ²»Ã÷¡£µ¹ÊÇ×î³õµÄÓйط¨ÂɵĵÀµÂ»³ÒÉÂÛ»òÐí»áÓÐÖúÓÚ·¨ÂɵĵÀµÂÅúÅкͱä¸ï¡£
ÓÉ´ËÒìÒéÒý·¢³öÒÔÏÂÎÊÌâ¡£ÆäÒ»£¬¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛµÖµ²²»ÁËÄÇЩÀ´×Ô¡°Êµ£¨Ö¤£©·¨·Ç·¨¡±µÄÅúÆÀ¡£Ëüº¬º¬ºýºýµØÐû³Æ±»µ±×÷·¨ÂÉÀ´ÊµÊ©µÄÄÇЩ¹æÔò²¢²»±ØÈ»µØºÏºõ×ÔÈ»·¨£¬Õâ¾Í²úÉúÁËÒ»¸öµÀµÂÅúÅеÄÕýµ±ÀíÓÉ£º¼ÙÉè±»µ±×÷·¨ÂÉÀ´Ê©ÐеĹæÔòÊDz»¹«ÕýµÄ£¬ÄÇô£¬Ëü¾Í²»¾ßÓз¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔ£»½ø¶ø£¬ÊµÊ©ÄÇЩ·´¶Ô¹«Ãñ˽ÈËȨÀûµÄ¹æÔòÊÇÔÚ·¸×ï¡£
Æä¶þ£¬¸üÎªÖØÒªµÄÊÇ£¬¸÷ÖÖ·´¶ÔÒâ¼ûÖ¼ÔÚͨ¹ý½Òʾ¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåµÄÒ»¸öʵ¼ùÐÔÎÊÌ⡪¡ªËüËÆºõ·¸ÁË·ÖÀàѧÉϵĴíÎ󡪡ªÀ´Ö¸³öÆäȱÏÝ¡£¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧ¼Ù¶¨Ò»ÖÖÉç»áʵ¼ù£¨ÈçÖÆ¶¨·¨ÂÉ£©µÄºËÐÄÔÚÓÚÆä¸ÅÄîÐÔ½âÊÍ¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬²»¶ÏÍÆ¶¯¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧ·¢Õ¹µÄ±ãÊÇͨ¹ý˵Ã÷Ïȴ棨pre£exsiting£©Ê±´úµÄÉç»áÉú»îÀ´Ï꾡µØ²ûÊö·¨ÂÉÏà¹Ø¸ÅÄî¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬Èç¹ûÏÈ´æÊ±´úµÄ×´¿öδÄܵÃÒÔ³ä·Ö˵Ã÷µÄ»°£¬ÄÇô£¬·¨µÄ¸ÅÄîÐÔÀíÂÛ×ÔÈ»»áÕÐÖÂÅúÅС£µ«Èç¹ûÎÒÃǽöÒò¶ÔÆäÑ¡ÔñµÄÆÀ¼Û±ê×¼ºÍʵ¼ùÎÊÌâ´æÓÐÒìÒé¾Í¶ÔÆä´ó¼ÓÌ¢·¥£¬Õâ¿ÖÅÂÓÐʧ¹«ÔÊ¡£
×î½ü£¬±Ï¿Ë˹Òý·¢ÁËÒ»³¡ÆÄÓÐÐËζµÄÌÖÂÛ¡£Óë·ÆÄá˹£¨John Finnis£¬1980£©Ò»ÂöÏà³ÐµÄ£¬±Ï¿Ë˹·´¶Ô°Ñ°¢¿üÄǺͲ¼À³¿Ë¶ÙÊÓΪÊǸÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼Ò£¬ËûÈÏΪËùν¡°²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨Âɲ»ÊÇ·¨¡±ÕâÒ»Â۶ϲ»Ó¦¸Ã½ö´Ó×ÖÃæÉϼÓÒÔÀí½â£º
Ëùν¡°²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨Âɸù±¾²»ÊÇ·¨¡±£¬ÎÒÏ룬×îºÏÀíµÄ½âÊÍÓ¦¸ÃÊÇ£º²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨Âɲ»ÄÜÔÚ¡°ÍêÈ«ÒâÒåÉÏ¡±£¨in the fullest sense£©Ëã×÷ÊÇ·¨¡£ÕâÕýÈçÎÒÃÇͨ³£Ìá¼°µÄijЩרҵÈËÊ¿£¬ËûÃǾ߱¸ÏàÓ¦µÄÎÄÆ¾ºÍ×ÊÀú£¬µ«ËƺõǷȱ±ØÒªµÄÄÜÁ¦£¬ÕâʱÎÒÃÇ˵£¬¡°Ëý²»ÊÇÂÉʦ¡±»ò¡°Ëû²»ÊÇÒ½Éú¡±¡£Êµ¼ÊÉÏ£¬ÕâÖÖ˵·¨Ö»ÊDZíÃ÷£ºÎÒÃÇÈÏΪËûÃÇÓдËÍ·ÏΣ¬µ«²»ÄÜʤÈθÃÖ°Îñͨ³£ËùÓ¦¾ß±¸µÄÔðÈΡ£Í¬ÑùµÄ£¬ËµÒ»Ìõ·ÇÕýÒåµÄ·¨ÂÉ¡°²»ÊÇÕæÕýµÄ·¨ÂÉ¡±£¨not really law£©£¬ÕâÒ²Òâζ×Å£ºÎÒÃÇÏëÖ¸³ö£¬Ëü²»ÏñÄÇЩÓë¡°¸ß¼¶·¨¡±£¨higher law£©Ïà·ûºÏµÄ·¨ÂÉÒ»Ñù£¬ÄܳÐÔØÍ¬µÈµÄµÀµÂÁ¦Á¿»òÌṩͬµÈµÄÀíÓÉ£¨Bix 1996£¬226£©¡£
ÓÉÉϿɼû£¬±Ï¿Ë˹ÔÚÆÀ½é°¢¿üÄǺͲ¼À³¿Ë¶ÙʱËù³ÖµÄ¹Ûµã»ù±¾ÀàͬÓÚ½«ÔÚ±¾ÎĵÚÈý²¿·ÖÂÛ¼°µÄÔ¼º²¡¤·ÆÄá˹µÄÐÂ×ÔÈ»Ö÷Ò塣Ȼ¶ø£¬¾¡¹ÜÎÒÃÇ»òÐí»áÔÞͬBixµÄ¿´·¨£¬µ«³¤ÆÚÒÔÀ´°Ñ°¢¿üÄǺͲ¼À³¿Ë¶ÙÊÓ×÷¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼ÒµÄ´«Í³ÈÏʶ£¬Á¬Í¬ÕâÖÖÈÏʶÔÚÍÆ¶¯·¨Ñ§½ÌÓýÉϵļÛÖµ£¬ÎÒÃÇÏàÐÅ£¬ÎÞÂÛÈçºÎ£¬ËüµÄÓ°Ï컹»á³ÖÐøÏÂÈ¥¡£
¢ó.Ô¼º²¡¤·ÆÄá˹£¨John Finnis£©µÄÐÂ×ÔÈ»·¨Ö÷Òå
Ô¼º²¡¤·ÆÄá˹һֱÖÂÁ¦ÓÚÑо¿ºÍ·¢Õ¹°¢¿üÄÇÓë²¼À³¿Ë¶ÙµÄÀíÂÛ¡£ÈçͬBixÒ»Ñù£¬ËûÒ²ÈÏΪ°¢¿üÄǺͲ¼À³¿Ë¶ÙµÄ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ²»Äܱ»µ±×÷ÊÇ·¨ÂÉÏÖ´æ×´Ì¬µÄÒ»ÖÖ¸ÅÄîÐÔ½âÊÍ¡£ÔÚ·ÆÄá˹¿´À´£¬ÓëÆä˵¹Åµä×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåÕßÊÇÔÚ¹ØÐÄ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐԵĸÅÄîÐÔ½âÊÍ£¬²»Èç˵ËûÃǸü¼Ó×¢ÖØËµÃ÷Ö§³Å·¨ÂɵĵÀµÂЧÁ¦£º¡°×ÔÈ»·¨µÄÖîÏîÔÔò˵Ã÷ÁËʵÔÚ·¨µÄÔ¼ÊøÁ¦£¨´ËΪÍêÈ«ÒâÒåÉϵġ°Ô¼ÊøÁ¦¡±£©£¬ÉõÖÁÓÐһЩ·¨ÂÉÔ±¾²»ÄÜ´ÓÄÇЩÔÔòÖÐÍÆµ¼³öÀ´Ê±ÒàÊÇÈç´Ë¡±£¨Finnis 1980£¬23£24£©¡£ÖÁÓÚ·ÆÄá˹¶Ô½»µþÀíÂ۵Ŀ´·¨£¬ËûÈÏΪ·¨ÂɵĻù±¾¹¦ÄÜÔÚÓÚΪÕþ¸®µÄÇ¿ÖÆÐÐΪÌṩһϵÁÐÕýµ±ÐԱ绤¡£Ò»Ìõ²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨ÂÉÔÚijÖ̶ֳÈÉÏÒ²¿ÉÒÔ»ñµÃºÏ·¨ÐÔ£¬Ö»ÊÇËü²»×ãÒÔ³ÉΪÕþ¸®²ÉÈ¡Ç¿ÖÆÊֶεÄÕýµ±ÀíÓÉ£¬Òò´Ë£¬Ëü²»¾ß±¸ÍêÈ«ÒâÒåÉϵÄÔ¼ÊøÁ¦¡£»»ÑÔÖ®£¬Ò»Ìõ²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨Âɲ»ÄÜʵÏÖÔ̺¬ÓÚ·¨ÂɸÅÄîÖеĵÀµÂÀíÏ룬Òò¶øÕâÑùµÄ·¨¼´Ê¹¾ßÓз¨ÂÉÔ¼ÊøÁ¦£¬ÈÔ²»ÄܳÆÎªÍêÈ«µÄ·¨¡£
¼Ì³ÐÁ˹ŵä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ£¬·ÆÄá˹µÄ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ¼ÈÊÇÂ×ÀíµÄÒ²ÊÇ·¨Âɵġ£Ëû³ÂÁÐÁËÒ»×é¾ßÓÐÆ½µÈ¼ÛÖµµÄ»ù±¾ÐÒ¸££¨basic goods£©£ºÉúÃü£¬½¡¿µ£¬ÖªÊ¶£¬ÓÎÏ·£¬ÓÑÒ꣬×ڽ̺ÍÃÀµÄÌåÑé¡£²¢ÇÒÈÏΪ£ºÉÏÊöÐÒ¸£ÖеÄÿһÏî½ÔÒòÈËÐÔµÄÔµ¹Ê¶ø¾ßÓÐÄÚÔڵĶÀÁ¢¼ÛÖµ£¬ÕâЩ¼ÛÖµÖ®²úÉúÓë´æÔÚ£¬½ö½öÊÇÒòΪÆä±¾Éí¶ø·ÇËü¸¨ÖúÆäËü¸£ìíµÄ¹¦ÄÜ¡£Í¬Ê±£¬·ÆÄá˹ÈÏΪ£¬Ã¿Ò»¸£ìí»¹ÊÇÆÕÊÊÐԵģ¬Ò²¾ÍÊÇ˵£¬ËüÔÚÈκÎʱºò¶ÔÈκÎÃñ×åµÄÎÄ»¯¶¼ÊÊÓᣰ´ÕÕÕâÖֹ۵㣬µÀµÂ½äÂɵÄÄ¿µÄ£¬Ö¼ÔÚΪ׷ÇóÕâЩ»ù±¾ÐÒ¸£É趨Â×Àí¿ò¼Ü£»µÀµÂ½äÂÉÄÜÖ¸ÒýÎÒÃÇÔÚÏ໥³åÍ»µÄ¸£ìíÖÐ×ö³öÑ¡Ôñ²¢¾ö¶¨Ò»¸öÈËÔÚʵÏÖËûËù×·ÇóµÄ»ù±¾ÐÒ¸£Ê±Ó¦¸Ã×öЩʲô¡£ ÔÚ·ÆÄá˹¿´À´£¬·¨ÂɵĹؼü¾ÍÔÚÓÚÌṩһϵÁÐȨÍþÐԵĹæÔòÒÔ½â¾öÈËÃÇÔÚ¹²Í¬×·Çó»ù±¾ÐÒ¸£µÄ¹ý³ÌÖÐËù²úÉúµÄ³åÍ»ºÍì¶Ü£¬×îÖÕµÃÒÔÍÆ¶¯¹²Í¬ÐÒ¸£µÄʵÏÖ¡£ËûÒò´Ë¶ø×ܽáÁË×Ô¼ºµÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ£º
¡°·¨ÂÉ¡±ÕâÒ»ÊõÓïÖ÷ÒªÖ¸µÄÊÇÕâÑùһЩ¹æÔò£ºËüÃDZ»Ò»¸öÈ·¶¨µÄ¡¢ÓÐЧµÄȨÍþ»ú¹¹£¨´Ë»ú¹¹µÄ×éÖ¯ÓÖ·´¹ýÀ´ÒòΪ·¨ÂɹæÔòµÄ¹æ¶¨¶ø¸ü¼Ó±ê×¼»¯¡¢ÖƶȻ¯£©ÎªÁË¡°Õû¸ö¡±Éç»áµÄÀûÒæËùÖÆ¶¨£»²¢ÇÒ£¬ÒÀ¿¿Ë¾·¨»ú¹¹ÔÚ·¨ÂÉÖ¸ÒýÏÂʵÐеÄÖÆ²ÃÀ´Î¬³Ö¡£ËùÓÐÕâЩ¹æÔòºÍ»úÖÆµÄ×ܺͣ¬±»ÓÃÒÔÖ¸µ¼ÈËÃǺÏÀíµØ½â¾öÔÚʵÏÖ¹²Í¬ÐÒ¸£Ê±²úÉúµÄÐ×÷ÎÊÌ⣨Finnis 1980£¬276£©¡£
ͬʱ£¬Õâ¶ÎÂÛÊö»¹½øÒ»²½ÏÔʾÁË·ÆÄá˹¹ØÓÚ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐԵĹ۵㣺Ëû²¢²»ÈÏΪ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧ¾Í±ØÐëµÃͨ¹ýËùÓеĵÀµÂ¼ìÑé¡£Ëû˵£¬¡°Èç¹ûÒ»¸öÈËÈÏΪÎÒËù¶¨ÒåµÄ¡°·Ç·¨µÄ¹æÔò¶ø±»·¨ÂÉÅųýÔÚÍ⡱ÓëÎÒ¶¨ÒåÖÐµÄÆäËûÒªËØ²»Ïà¡¢»ò²»ÍêÈ«ÏàÎǺϵϰ£¬ÄÇËû¶à°ëÊÇÎó½âÁËÎÒÓйØÈËÐԵĸÅÄîºÍÎÒ¶ÔÕâÒ»¼Ù¶¨ÐÔ¸ÅÄîËù×÷µÄ²ûÊÍÐÔ˵Ã÷¡±£¨Finnis 1980£¬278£©¡£
ÎÞÂÛÈçºÎ£¬·ÆÄá˹ÏàÐÅ£ºÒ»Ìõ·¨¹æÈç¹û²»ÄÜÂú×ãÉÏÊöÇé¿ö£¨Ö¸ÎªÊµÏÖ¹²Í¬¸£ìí¶øÖÆ¶¨²¢Í¨¹ýµÀµÂ¼ìÑ顪¡ªÒëÕß×¢£©£¬ÄÇËü¾Í²»ÄÜÍêÈ«±íÃ÷·¨ÂɵÄÌØÐÔ£¬Òò´Ë£¬ËüÒ²²»ÄÜʹ¹«Ãñ¸ºÓÐã¡ÊØ·¨ÂɵÄÉñÊ¥ÒåÎñ¡£´Ó·¨Âɼ¼ÊõµÄ²ãÃæÀ´½²£¬²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨ÂÉÒ²ÐíÊÇÓÐÔ¼ÊøÁ¦µÄ£»µ«ÊÇËüÃDz»ÄÜΪÐÐΪÌṩµÀµÂÉϵÄÀíÓÉ¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬·ÆÄá˹Ö÷ÕÅ£¬¡°Ò»¸öͳÖÎÕßÔÚÖÆ¶¨¹æÕÂʱ£¬Èç¹û²»ÒÔ¹²Í¬ÐÒ¸£Îª³ö·¢µã¶ø½ö½ö¿¼ÂÇÆä¸öÈ˵ġ¢ÁÅÊôµÄ¡¢Õþµ³µÄ»òÆäËüСÅÉϵµÄÀûÒæ£¬»òÕßÔ¤ÏȾÍÅųâijЩ¸öÈ˺ÍÍÅÌåµÄºÏÀíÒªÇó£¬ÄÇô£¬ËûµÄͳÖÎȨÍþ´Ó¸ù±¾ÉϾÍÊÇÓÐȱÏݵġ±£¨Finnis 1980£¬352£©¡£¾ÍÒ»¸öͳÖÎÕßµÀµÂȨÍþµÄÖÕ¼«»ù´¡¶øÑÔ£¬¡°ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬ËûÓÐȨÁ¦¡¢Òò¶ø¾ÍÓÐÔðÈÎÖÆ¶¨Éç»áÐ×÷ÎÊÌâµÄ½â¾ö°ì·¨ÒÔÍÆ½ø¹²Í¬ÐÒ¸£µÄʵÏÖ¡±£¨Finnis 1980£¬351£©¡£
·ÆÄá˹µÄÀíÂÛ×÷ΪһÖÖ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ£¬½ÏÖ®¹Åµä×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåµÄ´«Í³½âÊÍËÆºõ¸ü¼ÓËÆÊǶø·Ç¡£µ«ÊÇ£¬ÕâÑùµÄËÆÊǶø·ÇÈ´ÒòΪÆäÀíÂ۵ĶÀÌØÐÔ¶ø»ò¶à»òÉٵشòÆÆÁË×ÔÈ»·¨´«Í³Ò»ÒÔ¹áÖ®µÄͳһ¡£ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬·ÆÄá˹µÄ¹Ûµã¿´ÆðÀ´µ¹ÏñºÍ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛµÄÀ϶ÔÊÖ¡ª¡ª·¨ÂÉʵ֤Ö÷Òå¸üΪÏàͶ£¬ÒòΪ·ÆÄá˹ÔÞͬ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔµÄÀ´Ô´ÂÛ£¨a source£based theory£©£¬¼´·¨ÂÉÒòÆäÀ´Ô´¶øÔÚ¡°¼¼ÊõÉÏÓÐЧ¡±£¨technically valid£©£¬µ«²»¹«ÕýµÄ·¨ÂÉÈ´²»ÄܶԹ«Ãñ¾ßÓоø¶ÔÔ¼ÊøÁ¦¡£Ëû£¨1996£©»¹ÈÏΪ£¬°¢¿üÄǵĹŵä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛÍêȫ֤Ã÷ÁËÈçϹ۵㣺ÈËÀàµÄ·¨ÂÉÊDZ»¡°´´É衱£¨posited£©³öÀ´µÄ¡£
¢ô.¸»ÀÕ£¨Lon L.Fuller£©µÄ³ÌÐò×ÔÈ»·¨¹Û
ºÍ·ÆÄá˹һÑù£¬¸»ÀÕ£¨1964£©Ò²·ñÆúÁ˸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼ÒµÄ¹Ûµã£¬Ëû²¢²»ÈÏΪӦ¸Ã¶Ô·¨µÄÄÚÈÝÊ©¼ÓʵÖÊÐԵĵÀµÂÔ¼Êø¡£µ«Óë·ÆÄá˹ÓÐËùÇø±ðµÄÊÇ£¬¸»ÀÕÖ÷ÕÅ·¨ÂɱØÐë·þ´Ó³ÌÐòÐÔµÀµÂ¡£°´ËûµÄ¿´·¨£¬ÈËÀà»î¶¯±ØÈ»ÊÇÒÔÄ¿µÄΪָÕëµÄ»òÕß˵ÈËÀà»î¶¯ÊÇÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄ£¬ÓÉ´Ë£¬ÈËÃÇ´Óʸ÷ÖÖ¸÷ÑùµÄ¾ßÌå»î¶¯¾ÍÊÇÒòΪÕâЩ»î¶¯ÄܰïÖúËûÃÇʵÏÖ×îÖÕµÄÄ¿µÄ¡£´ÓÕâ¸öÒâÒåÉ϶øÑÔ£¬¼ÈÈ»ÈËÀà»î¶¯ÔÚ±¾ÖÊÉÏÊÇÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄ£¬ÄÇô£¬¸÷ÖÖÌØÊâµÄ»î¶¯¾ÍÖ»ÄÜ´ÓËûÃǵÄÄ¿µÄºÍ½á¹ûÕâ¸ö½Ç¶ÈÇÐÈ룬·½¿É±»Àí½â¡£Í¬ÑùµÄµÀÀí£¬Á¢·¨×÷ΪһÏî»ù±¾µÄÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄ»î¶¯£¬ËüÒ²±ØÐëÒÀ¾ÝÆä»ù±¾¼ÛÖµºÍÄ¿±êÀ´Àí½â£º
ÓÉÕâЩÂÛÖøËùÌṩ¸øÎÒÃǵÄÄܱ»³ÆÎª¡°·¨µÄ¶¨Ò塱µÄΨһµÄ±í´ïʽ£¬µ½ÏÖÔÚΪֹ£¬ÒѾΪÎÒÃÇËùÊìϤ£¬¼´£º·¨ÄËÊÇʹÈËÃǵÄÐÐΪ·þ´Ó¹æÔòÖÎÀíµÄÊÂÒµ¡£Óë´ó¶àÊýÏÖ´úµÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂÛ²»Í¬£¬ÕâÖÖ¿´·¨½«·¨ÊÓΪһÖֻ£¬²¢ÇÒ½«·¨ÂÉÌåϵ¿´×÷ÊdzÖÐø²»¶ÏµÄÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄÖÖÖÖ³¢ÊԵIJúÎFuller 1964£¬106£©¡£
´ÓÉÏÊö¸ø³öµÄ·¨µÄ¶¨Ò壬ÎÒÃÇ¿ÉÒÔ¿´³ö£¬Ëü±ØÈ»Ô̺×ÅÈçϵĹ۵㣬¼´£º·¨µÄ×î»ù±¾µÄ¹¦ÄÜÔÚÓÚ£¬¡°Í¨¹ýÆÕ±é¹æÔòµÄÒýµ¼£¨Ê¹ÈËÃÇ¿ÉÒÔ½èÖú¹æÔòÈ·¶¨×Ô¼ºÐÐΪµÄ·½Ïò£©À´µ÷¿ØÈËÃǵÄÐÐΪ£¬ÒÔ×îÖճɾÍijÖÖÉç»áÖÈÐò¡±£¨Fuller 1965£¬657£©¡£
¸»ÀյŦÀûÖ÷ÒåµÄ·¨¸ÅÄ°µÊ¾×Å£¬³ý·Çijһ¹æÔòÄÜʵÏÖ·¨ÂÉÒýµ¼ÐÐΪµÄ»ù±¾¹¦ÄÜ£»·ñÔò£¬¾Í¾ø²»ÄÜËã×÷ÊÇ·¨¡£µ±È»£¬ÈçҪʵÏÖÕâÒ»¹¦ÄÜ£¬¹æÔòÌåϵ»¹ÐèÂú×ãÈçÏÂÌõ¼þ£º£¨1£©¹æÔò±ØÐëÊÇÒ»°ãµÄ¡¢¡°ÆÕͨ¡±µÄ£»£¨2£©¹æÔò±ØÐë¹ã·ºµØ¹«²¼£»£¨3£©¹æÔò±ØÐëÊÇʵ¼ÊÉÏ¿ÉÔ¤¼ûµÄ£»£¨4£©¹æÔò±ØÐëÒÔÒ»Öֿɱ»Àí½âµÄ·½Ê½±í´ï³öÀ´£»£¨5£©¹æÔòÖ®¼ä±ØÐëÏ໥е÷£»£¨6£©¹æÔò²»µÃÒªÇ󳬳öµ±ÊÂÈËÄÜÁ¦·¶Î§µÄÐÐΪ£»£¨7£©¹æÔò²»µÃ¹ýÓÚÆµ·±µÄ¸Ä±äÒÔÖÂÖ÷ÌåÎÞËùÊÊ´Ó£»£¨8£©¹æÔòµÄʵʩ±ØÐëÓëÆä¹æ¶¨ÏàÒ»Ö¡£
ÔÚ¸»ÀÕ¿´À´£¬Èç¹û¹æÔòÌåϵ²»ÄÜ×îµÍÏ޶ȵØÂú×ãÕâЩºÏ·¨ÐÔÔÔòµÄ»°£¬ÄÇôËüÃÇÒ²¾Í²»ÄÜʵÏÖͨ¹ý¹æÔòµ¼ÒýÈËÃǵÄÐÐΪ½ø¶øËÜÔìÉç»áÖÈÐòµÄÄ¿µÄ¡£¾ÙÀý¶øÑÔ£¬Ò»Ì×¹æÔòÌåϵÈô²»ÄÜÂú×ãµÚ£¨2£©Ìõ»òµÚ£¨4£©Ìõ£¬ÔòËü¾ÍÎÞ·¨Ö¸µ¼ÐÐΪ¡ª¡ªÒòΪÈËÃÇÎÞ´ÓÖªÏþ¹æÔòÒªÇóµÄµ½µ×ÊÇʲô¡£ÓÚÊÇ£¬¸»ÀÕ½«ËûµÄÕâ°ËÌõÔÔòÊÓ×÷·¨µÄ¡°ÄÚ²¿¡±£¨internal£©ÒªËضøÈÚÈë·¨µÄ´æÔÚ״̬ÖС£
¸»ÀÕÈÏΪ£¬ÕâЩÄÚ²¿ÔÔò¹¹³ÉÁËÒ»ÖÖµÀµÂ£¬ÒòΪ·¨ÂɱØÐëÔÚÒÔÏÂÁ½¸ö·½Ãæ¾ß±¸Êµ¼ÊµÄµÀµÂ¼ÛÖµ£º£¨1£©·¨ÂÉÒªÓÐÖúÓÚÉç»áÖÈÐòµÄÐγɣ»£¨2£©ÓûʵÏÖǰÊöÄ¿±ê¾Í±ØÐë×ðÖØÈ˵Ä×ÔÖ÷Ȩ£¬ÒòΪ¹æÔò±ØÈ»Òª¶ÔÈ˵ÄÐÐΪÆð×÷Ó᣼ÈÈ»¹æÔòÌåϵ±ØµÃ×îµÍÏ޶ȵØ×ñѺϷ¨ÐÔÔÔò·½ÄÜʵÏÖµÀµÂ¼ÛÖµµÄÄ¿±ê£¬ÄÇôËüÃÇ×ÔȻҲ¾ÍÈ·Á¢ÁËÒ»ÖÖµÀµÂ¡£·´¹ýÀ´Ëµ£¬¼ÈÈ»ÕâЩµÀµÂÔÔò£¨¼´ºÏ·¨ÐÔÔÔò¡ª¡ªÒëÕß×¢£©ÉøÍ¸½ø·¨µÄ´æÔÚ״̬֮ÖУ¬ËüÃǾ͡°ÄÚ»¯¡±ÓÚ·¨ÂÉ£¬²¢´ú±íÁË·¨ÂÉÓëµÀµÂµÄÒ»ÖÖ¸ÅÄîÐÔÁªÏµ¡£ÕâÑùµÄ¹Ûµãµ±È»ÊÇͬÓڹŵä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ¶øÒìÓÚ·ÆÄá˹µÄ£¬»»¾ä»°½²£¬¸»ÀÕÔÞͬ½»µþÀíÂ۵ĺËÐIJ¿·Ö£¬ËûÒ²Òò´Ë¶ø±»»®Èë¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼ÒÖ®ÁС£
µ«ÊÇ£¬¸ÅÄîÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛÓë¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛÒ²ÓÐ×ÅһЩ»ù±¾µÄÇø±ð¡£Ê×ÏÈ£¬¸»ÀÕ·´¶Ô¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼ÒËùÈÏΪµÄ±ØÐë¶Ô·¨ÂɵÄÄÚÈݼÓÒÔµÀµÂÏÞÖÆµÄ¹Ûµã£¬È¡¶ø´úÖ®µÄÊÇ£¬ËûÖ÷ÕŶԷ¨ÂɵÃÒÔÖÆ¶¨ºÍʵʩµÄ³ÌÐò»úÖÆ½øÐбØÒªµÄµÀµÂÖÆÔ¼£º¡°ÎÒËù³ÆµÄ·¨ÂɵÄÄÚÔÚµÀµÂ¡¡Ö¸µÄÊÇÒ»ÖÖ³ÌÐò×ÔÈ»·¨£¬Ëü¹Ø×¢µÄ£¬²¢·ÇÊÇ·¨Âɹ淶µÄʵÌåÄ¿±ê£¬¶ø½ö½öÊÇÒ»Ì×ÖÎÀíÈËÃÇÐÐΪµÄ¹æÔòÌåϵÈçºÎ±»¹¹½¨ºÍʵʩµÄ·½Ê½£¬ÒÔ±ãÕâÌ×¹æÔòÌåÏµÕæÕýÓÐЧͬʱÓÖÄÜʵÏÖËüµÄÒâͼ¡±£¨Fuller 1964£¬96£97£©¡£
Æä´Î£¬¸»Àս綨·¨ÂÉÓëµÀµÂÖ®¼äµÄ¸ÅÄîÐÔÁªÏµ£¬½ÏÖ®¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼Ò¶øÑÔ£¬´¦ÓÚÒ»¸ö¸üΪ³éÏóµÄˮƽÉÏ¡£¾ßÌåµØËµ£¬¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼Ò½«µÀµÂÉ趨ΪÏÞÖÆÃ¿Ò»¸ö±ð·¨ÂÉ£¨individual law£©µÄʵÖÊÐÔÒªËØ£»°´ÕâÖֹ۵㣬һÌõ²»¹«ÕýµÄ¹æÔò£¬ÔÚ¸ÅÄîÉÏÒ²¾ÍɥʧÁ˺Ϸ¨µÄ×ʸñ¡£Ïà·´µØ£¬¸»ÀÕÈ´ÈÏΪµÀµÂÖ»ÊǶÔÕû¸ö·¨ÂÉÌåϵ´æÔÚ״̬£¨the existence of a legal system£©µÄÒ»ÖÖÔ¼Êø£º¡°¶Ô°ËÔÔòÖÐÈÎÒâÒ»ÔÔòµÄÑÏÖØÆÆ»µ£¬Æä½á¹û²»½ö½öµ¼ÖÂÁËÒ»ÖÖ¶ñ·¨Ìåϵ£¬ËüÉõÖÁ¸ù±¾¾Í²»Åä³ÆÖ®ÎªÊÇ·¨ÂÉÌåϵ¡±£¨Fuller 1964£¬96£97£©¡£
µ±È»£¬¸»ÀյijÌÐòÐÔ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛÒ²ÕÐÖÂÁË´óÁ¿ÒìÒé¡£¹þÌØ£¨H.L.A.Hart£©µÄ¹Ûµã±ãÊÇÆäÖÐÖ®Ò»¡£¹þÌØ²»Ô޳ɸ»ÀÕËù˵µÄËùν¡°·¨ÂÉÔÔò¹¹³ÉÁËÒ»ÖÖÄÚÔÚµÀµÂ¡±£»Ïà·´£¬ËûÈÏΪÕâÊÇ»ìÏýÁ˵ÀµÂÓëʵЧµÄ¸ÅÄ
×÷Õߣ¨Ö¸¸»ÀÕ¡ª¡ªÒëÕß×¢£©¼á³Ö°Ñ·¨ÂÉÔÔò¹éÈë¡°µÀµÂ¡±µÄ·¶³ë£¬ÕâÕýÊǵ¼ÖÂËû±¾È˺ͶÁÕß˼ά»ìÂÛ¸ÅÄîµÄÔ´Í·¡£¾¡¹ÜÕâЩ¼¼ÊõÐÔÔÔò´Ó·¨ÂɲÙ×÷²ãÃæÉÏÀ´½²·Ç³£ÓÐЧ£¬µ«½«¡°ÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄ»î¶¯¡±ºÍ¡°µÀµÂ¡±ÕâÁ½¸ö¸ÅÄî·Ö¿ªÀ´Àí½âÈ´ÊÇÖÁ¹ØÖØÒªµÄ¡£¸»ÀÕµÄÖØ´óʧÎó¾ÍÔÚÓÚ°ÑÉÏÊöÁ½¸ö¸ÅÄî»ìΪһ̸ÁË¡£±ÈÈ磬Ͷ¶¾ºÁÎÞÒÉÎʵØÊÇÒ»ÖÖÓÐÄ¿µÄµÄ»î¶¯£¬ÇÒÕâÖÖÒâͼҲ³£±íÏÖΪһϵÁÐÄÚÔÚÔÔò¡££¨ÔÔòÒ»£º¡°Ö»ÒªÖж¾Õß³öÏÖŻͷ´Ó¦£¬ÄÇô£¬²»ÂÛÕâÖÖ¶¾Ò©¶¾ÐÔÓжàÇ¿£¬¶¼²»ÖÁÓÚÖÂÃü¡£¡±£©µ«ÄãÒò´Ë˵Ͷ¶¾¡°ÒÕÊõ¡±µÄÖÖÖÖÔÔò¾ÍÊÇ¡°Í¶¶¾µÄµÀµÂ¡±£¬Õâ¿Ï¶¨ÊÇ»ìÏýÁË¡°ÊµÏÖÄ¿µÄµÄ¹¦Ð§¡±ºÍ¡°¸ù¾ÝµÀµÂ¶ÔÄ¿µÄ¼°»î¶¯×÷³öµÄ×îÖÕÆÀÅС±Ö®¼äµÄ½çÏÞ£¨Hart 1965£¬1285£86£©¡£
ÔÚ¹þÌØ¿´À´£¬ÈËÀàµÄËùÓÐÐÐΪ£¬°üÀ¨ÉÆÐУ¨ÈçÁ¢·¨£©ºÍ¶ñÐУ¨ÈçͶ¶¾£©£¬¶¼ÓÐÆä×ÔÉíµÄЧÂÊÔÔò¡£µ«µ±ÕâЩЧÂÊÔÔòÓëµÀµÂÏàÎ¥±³µÄʱºò£¬±ÈÈçǰÊöËùÌáµ½µÄͶ¶¾£¬ËüÃǾÍÓ¦¸Ã±»µÀµÂÔÔòËùÌÞ³ý¡£Òò´Ë£¬¾¡¹Ü¹þÌØÃãÇ¿³ÐÈÏÁ˸»ÀյİËÔÔòÄÚ»¯ÓÚ·¨ÂÉ´æÔÚ״̬£¬µ«Ëû¼á³ÖÕâ°ËÌõÔÔò²»×ãÒÔ¹¹³É·¨ÂÉÓëµÀµÂÖ®¼äµÄ¸ÅÄîÐÔÁªÏµ¡£
Òź¶µÄÊÇ£¬¹þÌØºöÂÔÁËÕâÑùÒ»¸öÊÂʵ£¬¼´£¬¸»ÀյİËÔÔò¿É¼æÊÎÁ½½Ç¡£Ò»·½Ã棬ÕâЩÔÔòµ±È»ÊÇЧÂÊÔÔò£»ÁíÒ»·½Ã棬ËüÃÇÒ²¿ÉÊÓ×÷¹«ÕýµÄµÀµÂÀíÏë¡£¾ÙÀýÀ´Ëµ£¬Îª±ãÓÚÖªÏþ£¬·¨ÂÉÓ¦¸Ã¹«¿ª¡ª¡ªÕâ»òÐíÊÇ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧµÄ±ØÒªÇ°Ì᣻ͬʱ£¬ËüÒ²ÊÇÒ»¸öµÀµÂÀíÏë¡£Èç¹ûÕþ¸®ÊµÊ©ÄÇЩδ±»¹«¿ªµÄ¹æÔòÒÔÖÂÃñÖÚÎÞ´ÓÁ˽ⷨÂÉÌá³öµÄÖÖÖÖÒªÇó£¬ÕâÔÚµÀÒåÉÏÏÔÈ»ÊDz»ºÏÀíµÄ¡£Í¬ÑùµÄµÀÀí£¬ÎÒÃÇÒ²½«Õþ¸®Ê©ÐÐËݼ°¼ÈÍùµÄ·¨¹æ¡¢ÄÚ²¿²»Í³Ò»µÄ·¨¹æºÍÒªÇ󲻿ÉÄÜÊÂÏîµÄ·¨¹æÊÓΪÊDz»ÒåµÄ¡£Í¶¶¾»òÐíÓÐÆäÄÚÔÚµÄЧÂʱê×¼£¬µ«µ±ÕâЩ±ê×¼ÓëµÀµÂÀíÏëÏà³åͻʱËüÃDZ㲻ÔÙÊǺϷ¨ÐÔÔÔò¡£
È»¶ø£¬¸»ÀÕ°ËÔÔòÄÚ»¯ÓÚ·¨ÂÉ£¬Êµ¼ÊÉÏÊÇ×÷ΪЧÂÊÔÔò¶ø·ÇµÀµÂÀíÏëÔÚ·¢»Ó×÷Óõġ£¸»ÀÕ±¾ÈË´ó¸ÅÒ²²»µÃ²»³ÐÈÏ£¬·¨ÂɵÄʵ¼ÊÔË×÷ÓëºÏ·¨ÐÔÔÔòÖ®¼ä´æÔÚÏ൱´óµÄ¾àÀë¡£ÕâÑùµÄ¡°Âä²î¡±ÎÞÒÉʹÈË·´¸Ð¡£²»¹ý»°ÓÖ˵»ØÀ´£¬Ö»Óе±´ËÖÖÇé¿öµ¼Ö·¨Âɲ»ÄÜʵÏÖÆäÖ¸ÒýÈËÃÇÐÐΪÕâÒ»»ù±¾¹¦ÄÜʱ£¬ÈËÃDzŻáÒâʶµ½ÎÊÌâµÄÑÏÖØÐÔ¡£ÖÁÓÚÕâЩ£¨µÀµÂ£©ÔÔò±»Ð´½ø·¨ÂÉÖУ¬¶à°ëÊÇÒòΪËüÃÇÄÜ·¢»ÓʵЧ£¬¶ø·ÇÔÚÓÚËüÃÇÊǵÀµÂÀíÏë¡£
¢õ.ÂÞÄɵ¡¤µÂÎÖ½ð£¨Ronald Dworkin£©µÄ¡°µÚÈýÀíÂÛ¡±
ÂÞÄɵ¡¤µÂÎÖ½ðµÄ·¨µÄ¡°µÚÈýÀíÂÛ¡±×îºÃ±»Àí½âΪÊǶԷ¨ÂÉʵ֤Ö÷ÒåµÄÒ»ÖÖ»ØÓ¦¡£ÔÚËû¿´À´£¬·¨ÂÉʵ֤Ö÷Òå»ù±¾ÉÏÓÉÒÔÏÂÈý¸öÀíÂÛÖ§Ïî¹¹³É£ºÉç»áÊÂʵÀíÂÛ£¨the Social Fact Thesis£©£¬ºÏÒâÀíÂÛ£¨the Conventionality Thesis£©ºÍ¿É·ÖÀëÐÔÀíÂÛ£¨the Separablity Thesis£©¡£ËùνÉç»áÊÂʵÀíÂÛ£¬Ö¸µÄÊÇ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔ±ØÐëÀ´×ÔijÀàÉç»áÊÂʵµÄÖÕ¼«¹¦ÄÜ¡£»»¾ä»°Ëµ£¬ÕâÖÖÀíÂÛÖ÷ÕÅ£º×îÖÕÄܹ»½âÊÍ·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐԵģ¬ÄËÔÚijÀàÉç»áÊÂʵµÄ³öÏÖ£¬ÓÈÆäÊÇÁ¢·¨»ú¹ØµÄÕýʽȷÈϺÍÐû²¼¡£ ºÏÒâÀíÂÛÔòÖØÔÚÇ¿µ÷·¨ÂɵĺÏÒâÐÔÌØÕ÷£¬Ðû³ÆÄܹ»¸³Óè·¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔµÄÄÇЩÉç»áÊÂʵ֮ËùÒÔÊÇȨÍþµÄ£¬ÄËÊÇ»ùÓÚÒ»ÖÖÉç»áºÏÒâ¡£°´´Ë¹Ûµã£¬ÕýÓÉÓÚ¹ÙÔ±ÃÇͨ¹ýÃ÷ʾºÍĬÐí¶ø´ï³ÉµÄÐÒ飬ʹµÃµÃÒÔÅжÏÈκθø¶¨µÄ¹æÔòÊÇ·ñÄܳɯäΪ·¨ÂɹæÔòµÄ±ê×¼¾ßÓÐÁËÔ¼ÊøÁ¦¡£ÈçÎÒÃÇËùÖª£¬ÃÀ¹úÏÜ·¨µÄÎÞÉÏȨÍþ¾ÍÊÇÀ´×ÔÓÚÕâÑùÒ»¸öÊÂʵ£¬¼´£¬ËüÔÚÐÎʽÉÏ»ñµÃÁËÈ«ÃÀÎåÊ®¸öÖݵÄÅú×¼¡£
¶øËùν¿É·ÖÀëÐÔÀíÂÛ£¬¾Í×îͨ³£µÄ±ê×¼¶øÑÔ£¬½ö½öÊǼòµ¥µØ·ñ¶¨×ÔÈ»·¨Ë¼ÏëµÄ½»µþÀíÂÛ¡£ÔÚʵ֤Ö÷Ò巨ѧÕßÑÛÖУ¬·¨ÂɵĹæÔòºÍµÀµÂÖ®¼ä²¢ÎÞʲô¸ÅÄîÉϵĽ»²æ¡£¹þÌØ£¨Hart£©¾Í´Ë½øÒ»²½Ö¸³ö£¬¿É·ÖÀëÀíÂ۵ġ°ÄÚÈݺܼòµ¥£¬Ëü¾ø²»ÈÏΪ·¨ÂÉÓбØÒªÈ¥¸´ÖÆÄ³Ð©µÀµÂÒªÇ󡪡ª¾¡¹ÜÊÂʵ¾³£Èç´Ë¡±£¨Hart 1994£¬185£186£©¡£
µÂÎֽ𷴶Ôʵ֤Ö÷ÒåµÄÉç»áÊÂʵÀíÂÛ£¬ÒòΪËûÈÏΪÓÐЩ·¨ÂÉÔÔòµÄȨÍþÐÔÊDz»ÄÜÓÃÉç»áÊÂʵÀ´½âÊ͵ġ£±ÈÈç˵£¬ÒÉÄѰ¸¼þµÄÅоö£¬·¨¹ÙÃdz£³£»áÒý֤һЩµÀµÂÂÉÁºÜÃ÷ÏÔ£¬ÕâЩµÀµÂÂÉÁȻ²»ÊǵÃ×Ô¼¯ÌåÈϿɵķ¨ÂÉÓÐЧÐÔ±ê×¼¡£
ÔÚÀ׸ùËßÅÁ¶ûĬ£¨Riggs v. Palmer£©Ò»°¸[3] ÖУ¬·¨Í¥±ØÐëÒª½â¾öµÄÎÊÌâÊÇ£¬Ä±É±ÕßÓ¦·ñ´ÓËûµÄÊܺ¦È˵ÄÒÅÖöÖлñÒæ¡£°¸¼þÉóÀíµÄµ±Ê±£¬¼ÈûÓÐÑϸñµÄ·¨Ìõ¡¢Ò²Ã»ÓÐÒÔÍùµÄÅÐÀýÃ÷È·¹æ¶¨½ûÖ¹Ð×ÊÖ´ÓËûµÄÊܺ¦ÕßÒÅÖöÖлñÒæ¡£µ«¾¡¹ÜÈç´Ë£¬·¨Í¥»¹ÊÇÅоö±»¸æÎÞȨ¼Ì³ÐËûÓÉÊܺ¦ÕßÒÅÖöÖС°Ó¦µÃ¡±µÄÒŲú£¬ÒòΪÔÊÐíËû´ÓÈç´Ë±¯²ÒµÄ´íÎóÖÐÊÜÒæÕâ±¾Éí¾ÍÊÇÒ»¸öÑÏÖØµÄ´íÎó¡£µÂÎÖ½ðÈÏΪ£¬·¨Í¥¶Ô´Ë°¸µÄÅоöÕýÊÇÒýÓÃÁËÈçÏ¡°ÔÔò£¬¼´£¬È˲»Ó¦´ÓËû×ÔÉíµÄ´íÎóÖлñÒæ¡£ÕâÒ»ÔÔò×÷ΪһÖÖDZÔÚ¹æÔò¶Ô¿¹×ÅÒÅÖöµÄÏà¹Ø·¨Âɹ涨£¬²¢ÇÒͨ¹ýÕâÒ»·½Ê½Ê¹µÃǰÊöµÄ·¨Âɹ涨»ñµÃÁËÒ»ÖÖеĽâÊÍ¡£¡±£¨Dworkin 1977£¬29£©
µÂÎÖ½ðÈÏΪ£¬ÔÚÀ׸ùÒ»°¸ÖУ¬·¨Í¥ËùÔ®ÒýµÄÄÇÌõÔÔò²¢Ã»ÓÐÙÔÔ½·¨ÂɶøÉæ¼°¡°³¬·¨¡±£¨extralegal£©±ê×¼¡£Ç¡Ïà·´£¬¶Ô·¨Í¥¶øÑÔ£¬¼ÙÈô²»¿¼ÂÇÄÇÌõÔÔò£¬Ëü²ÅÓ¦Êܵ½ÅúÆÀ£»¼ÙÈôÒýÓõÄÄÇÌõÔÔò½ö½öÊÇÒ»Ìõ¡°³¬·¨¡±±ê×¼µÄ»°£¬Êµ¼ÊÉÏ£¬ÄãÕÒ²»µ½ÈκÎÕýµ±µÄÀíÓÉÀ´Ö¤Ã÷ÕâÑù×öÊǸö´íÎó£¨Dworkin 1977£¬35£©¡£½ÓÏÂÀ´£¬µÂÎÖ½ðµÃ³öÁËÈçϽáÂÛ£º¶Ô·¨Í¥²ÉÄÉÕâÒ»ÔÔòµÄ×î¼Ñ½âÊ;ÍÊÇ£¬ÔÔò±¾ÉíÄË·¨ÂɵÄÒ»²¿·Ö¡£
²»½öÈç´Ë£¬µÂÎÖ½ð»¹ÏàÐÅ£¬ÉÏÊöÔÔò£¨ÀàËÆÀ׸ù°¸¼þÖÐÒýÓõÄÔÔò£©µÄ·¨ÂÉȨÍþ²¢·ÇÀ´×Ôµ¥´¿³öÓÚÐÎʽÐèÒªµÄ¡°Ðû²¼¡±ÕâÒ»Éç»áÊÂʵ¡£¡°¾¡¹ÜÕâЩÔÔò»òÐí¿É´ÓÁ¢·¨»ú¹¹µÄ¹Ù·½·¨°¸È¡µÃijЩ֧³Ö¡ª¡ªÉõÖÁÔÚÕâЩ¹Ù·½·¨°¸ÖÐÏêϸµØÁоÙÁ˾¹ý¼¯ÌåÈÏͬµÄÖÖÖÖ±ê×¼¡ª¡ªÕâЩÔÔòÒ²²»±ØÈ»µØ¾Íͬ·¨°¸½¨Á¢Æð×ã¹»³ä·Ö¡¢Ö±½ÓµÄÁªÏµ¡±£¨Dworkin 1977£¬41£©¡£
°´ÕÕµÂÎÖ½ðµÄ¿´·¨£¬À׸ùÔÔòµÄ·¨ÂÉȨÍþ×îºÃÄÜ´ÓÆäÄÚÈÝÉÏÕûÌåÐÔ£¨wholly£©µØ¼ÓÒÔ½âÊÍ¡£À׸ùÔÔòÊÇÓÐÔ¼ÊøÁ¦µÄ£¬²¿·ÖÔÒòÔÚÓÚËüÂú×ãÁË»ù±¾¹«ÕýµÄÒªÇó£¬ÕâÖÖÒªÇóÔÚÉç»á·¨ÂÉʵ¼ùµÄÕûÌå¹ý³ÌÖÐÒѾÈÚÈëµ½×î¼ÑµÄÅоöÀíÓÉÖС£µÂÎÖ½ðÈÏΪ£¬Ò»ÌõÓÐÔ¼ÊøÁ¦µÄÔÔòÖ®ËùÒÔ¾ßÓз¨ÂÉȨÍþ£¬ÄËÒòΪËü×÷Ϊһ¸öÕûÌåÄÜ×î´óÏ޶ȵضÔÉç»á·¨ÂÉʵ¼ù½øÐÐ×î¼ÑµÄµÀµÂ±ç»¤¡£
µÂÎÖ½ðÏàÐÅ£¬Ä³Ò»·¨ÂÉÔÔòÈôÒª×î´óÏ޶ȵشٳÉÕâÑùµÄ±ç»¤µ±ÇÒ½öµ±ËüÂú×ãÈçÏÂÌõ¼þʱ·½ÄܳÉÁ¢£º¢ÅÕâÒ»ÔÔò·ûºÏÏÖÐеķ¨Âɾ«Éñ£»¢ÆÂú×ãÌõ¼þ¢ÅµÄÕâÒ»ÔÔòͬʱҲÊÇ×î¾ßµÀµÂÎüÒýÁ¦µÄ±ê×¼£¬¶þÕßȱһ²»¿É¡£»»ÑÔÖ®£¬Ëùνǡµ±µÄ·¨ÂÉÔÔòÒ²¾ÍÊǾ¡¿ÉÄܵØÊ¹·¨ÂÉʵÏÖ×î¼ÑµÀµÂ»¯µÄÒ»Ìõ;¾¶¡£ÔÚ´Ë»ù´¡ÉÏ£¬µÂÎÖ½ð¼ÌÐøËµ£¬·¨ÔºÅоöÊÇ¿ÉÒÔÒ²Ó¦¸Ã±»¡°·Ò롱µÄ£º
·¨¹ÙÔÚÉóÀíÒÉÄѰ¸¼þʱӦͨ¹ý¸÷ÖÖ;¾¶È¥¡°·Ò롱¹²Í¬ÌåµÄÕþÖνṹ£¬È磺ÔÚÄÇЩÒâÒåÉîÔ¶µÄÏÜ·¨ÐÔ¹æÔòºÍÇÖȨÐÐΪ·¨»òºÏͬ·¨µÄϸ½ÚÐÔ°²ÅÅÖдæÔÚ´óÁ¿µÄÕþÖεÀµÂÔÔò£¬·¨¹ÙÓ¦¾¡Á¦µØ´ÓÖÐȥѰÕÒËûÃÇÄÜÕҵõ½µÄ×î¼ÑÅоöÀíÓÉ£¨Dworkin 1982£¬165£©¡£
ÓÉ´Ë£¬Õâ¾Í²úÉúÁ˽øÐгɹ¦¡°·Ò롱µÄÁ½¸öÒª¼þ¡£ÆäÒ»£¬¼ÈÈ»·ÒëÖ»ÓÐÔÚÎªÌØ¶¨Éç»áµÄÌØ¶¨»î¶¯½øÐб绤µÄÒâÒåÉϲÅÊdzɹ¦µÄ£¬ÄÇô£¬·Òë¾Í±ØÐëÒª·ûºÏʵ¼ù»î¶¯£¬½øÑÔÖ®±ØÐë·ûºÏÏÖÐеÄÕâЩ»î¶¯ÄÚÔڵķ¨Âɹ涨ÐÔ¡£Æä¶þ£¬¼ÈÈ»·ÒëÒâÔÚΪÕâЩ»î¶¯ÌṩµÀµÂ±ç»¤£¬ÄÇô£¬Ëü¾Í±ØÐëÒÀÕÕµÀµÂµÄ±ê×¼×î´óÏ޶ȵØÌåÏÖÕâÒ»µã¡£
»ùÓÚ´Ë£¬µÂÎÖ½ð¼ÌÐøÕ¹¿ªËûµÄÂÛÊö£ºÒ»¸ö·¨¹Ù´óÖÂÓ¦¸ÃÕâÑùÀ´¡°·Ò롱һ¸ö°¸¼þ£¬
ΪÁËÄÜÈ·Á¢Ò»¸öÊʵ±µÄ¿É¡°±»½ÓÊÜ¡±µÄ³ß¶È£¬[Ðìˬ1] [Ðìˬ2] Ò»¸ö˼ÂÇÖÜÈ«µÄ·¨¹ÙÊ×ÏÈÓ¦¸ÃΪËû×Ô¼º½¨Á¢Ò»¸ö´óÖµÄÊʺϸ÷Àà°¸¼þµÄ·Òë¡°×ÊÁÏ¡±µÄ¡°ãС±£¨threshold£©¡£È»ºó£¬Èç¹û¸Ã¡°ãС±ÖÐijһ·¨ÌõµÄ·Òë²»Ö¹Ò»ÖÖ£¬ËûÓ¦¸ÃÄÜ×÷³öÃ÷ÖǵÄÑ¡Ôñ¡£ÕâÑùµÄÑ¡Ôñ²»½ö½öÊÇÔÚÁ½¸ö´ð°¸¼ä½øÐÐÉîÈëºÍ¾«Ï¸µÄ±È½Ï£»¸üÖØÒªµÄÊÇ£¬Ëû±ØÐëÖ§³ÖÄǸö¡°ÊµÖÊÉÏ¡±¸üºÃµÄ½âÊÍ£¬Ò²¾ÍÊÇ˵£¬×î½Ó½üÓÚËûËùÔ޳ɵÄÕþÖÎÀíÏëµÄÄÇÖÖ½âÊÍÓÅÏÈ£¨Dworkin 1982£¬171£©¡£
½ÓÏÂÀ´£¬ÕýÈçµÂÎÖ½ðËù¹¹ÏëµÄÄÇÑù£¬·¨¹Ù±ØÐ뿪ʼ×ÅÊÖ×îÖÕµÄ˾·¨¾ö²ß£¨ÕâÓеãÀàËÆÓÚ×÷µÀµÂÕÜѧµÄÁ·Ï°£©¡£¼´ÊÇ˵£¬Ëû±ØÐë¡°ÔÚÄÇЩÈÚÈëºÏÀíµÄ·¨ÂÉÀíÂ۵ĵÀµÂÔÔòÖÐÑ¡Ôñ³öÔÚʵÖÊÉϺÍÖÆ¶ÈÉ϶¼×îÊʺϴý¾öÎÊÌâµÄÒ»Ìõ×÷ΪÅоöÀíÓÉÀ´¶Ï°¸¡±£¨Dworkin 1977£¬66£©¡£
µ±È»£¬°´µÂÎÖ½ðµÄ˵·¨£¬ÕâÒ»¹ý³ÌͬʱҲÊÇ¡°ÂÉʦÃDZØÐë²»¶ÏµØÉîÈëÕþÖκ͵ÀµÂÀíÂ۵Ĺý³Ì¡±¡£ÊÂʵÉÏ£¬ÔÚÒÔºóµÄÖø×÷ÖУ¬µÂÎÖ½ð×ߵøüÔ¶¡£ËûÉù³Æ£¨Õâ¶à¶àÉÙÉÙÈÃÈËÓеãÄÑÒÔÖÃÐÅ£©£¬¡°Èκη¨¹ÙµÄ¹Ûµã±¾Éí¾ÍÊÇÒ»Ìõ·¨ÂÉÕÜѧ£¬ÉõÖÁµ±ÕÜѧ±»ÕڱΣ¬ÄÇЩ¿É¼ûµÄÕùÂÛÈÔÈ»±»ÒýÖ¤ºÍÊÂʵËùͳÖÎ×Å¡±£¨Dworkin 1986£¬90£©¡£
µÂÎÖ½ðÏàÐÅËûµÄ˾·¨Ö°ÔðÂÛÊÇÆäËùνȨÀûÀíÂÛ£¨Rights Thesis£©µÄ²úÎï¡£¾Ý´Ë·¨¹ÙµÄÖ°Ôð×ÜÊÇÔÚ²»¶ÏµØÊµÊ©ºÍ¹®¹ÌÏÈÔÚȨÀû£¨pre£existing rights£©£º¡°¼´Ê¹ÔÚ´¦Àíijһ°¸¼þʱ»¹Ã»ÓмÈÓеÄÏà¹Ø·¨Âɹ涨£¬Ò»¸öµ³ÍÅÈÔÓлú»áʤËß¡£ÒòΪ¶ÔÒÉÄѰ¸¼þµÄÉóÀí£¬·¨¹ÙÓÐÒåÎñÈ¥·¢ÏÖ£¨discover£©µ³ÍÅÓ¦ÓеÄȨÀû£¬¶ø²»ÊÇ»ØËÝÐԵط¢Ã÷£¨invent£©Ê²Ã´ÐµÄȨÀû¡±£¨Dworkin 1977£¬81£©¡£
ÔÚ¡°ÒÉÄѰ¸¼þ¡±ÖУ¬µÂÎÖ½ðÇø·ÖÁËÁ½À಻ͬµÄ·¨ÂÉÖ¤¾Ý¡£Ò»ÀàÊÇÕþÖÎÐÔµÄÖ¤¾Ý£¬ÕâÀàÖ¤¾Ý¡°Í¨¹ý±íÃ÷¾ö²ßÄÜ´Ù½ø»ò±£»¤Ä³Ò»¹²Í¬ÌåµÄ¼¯ÌåÄ¿±êÀ´Ö¤Ã÷ÕþÖξö²ßµÄÕýµ±ÐÔ¡±£¨Dworkin 1977£¬82£©¡£Ïà·´£¬ÁíÒ»ÀàÖ¤¾ÝÔòÊÇÔÔòÐÔµÄÖ¤¾Ý£¬ÕâÀà¡°Ö¤¾Ýͨ¹ýÏÔʾ¾ö²ß×ðÖØºÍº´ÎÀ¸öÌå»òȺÌåµÄȨÀûÀ´Ö¤Ã÷ÕþÖξö²ßµÄÕýµ±ÐÔ¡±£¨Dworkin 1977£¬82£©¡£
µÂÎÖ½ðÔڱȽÏÁ½ÀàÖ¤¾ÝʱÈÏΪ£¬ËäÈ»Á¢·¨µ±¾ÖºÜ¿ÉÄܺϷ¨µØ°ä²¼ÄÇЩ¾¹ýÕþÖÎÐÔÖ¤¾ÝÑéÖ¤µÄ·¨ÂÉ£¬µ«·¨Í¥ÔÚÉó°¸Ê±È´²»Ò»¶¨»áÑØÏ®ÕâЩ֤¾Ý£¬ÒòΪ¼´±ãÊÇÕþÖÎÉÏÊ×βһ¹áµÄÖ¤¾ÝÒ²²»ÄÜÌṩ×ã¹»³ä·ÖµÄÀíÓÉÀ´Ö§³Öijһµ³ÍŵÄȨÀûÐûÑÔ¶ø·´¶ÔÆäËüµ³ÍŵÄȨÀûÒªÇó¡£ÔÚµÂÎÖ½ð¿´À´£¬Ò»ÏîÏÈÔÚȨÀûµÄÒªÇó×îÖÕÖ»ÄܾÓÉÔÔòÐÔÖ¤¾Ý¼ÓÒÔ֤ʵ¡£ÕâÑùÒ»À´£¬Ë¾·¨Åоö±ØÈ»»áÈÏͬȨÀûÒªÇ󣬲¢ÇÒËüÃÇÒ²×îÖÕ½¨»ùÓÚÄÇЩÄÜΪ·¨ÂÉÔÔòÌṩ×î¼Ñ±ç»¤µÄµÀµÂÔÔòµÄÕûÌåÖ®ÉÏ¡£ ÎÒÃÇÐèҪעÒâµÄÊÇ£ºµÂÎÖ½ðÓйط¨ÂÉÔÔòºÍ˾·¨Ö°ÔðµÄ¹ÛµãÓë·¨ÂÉʵ֤Ö÷ÒåµÄÈýÏîºËÐÄÀíÂÛÊDz»Ò»Öµġ£µÂÎÖ½ðÖ÷ÕÅ·¨¹ÙÃDZØÐë°´ÕÕÏÈÑéµÄµÀµÂÔÔòÀ´½âÊÍʵÔÚ·¨£¬ÕâͬºÏÒâÀíÂÛÏàì¶Ü£»µÂÎÖ½ðÓÖÖ÷ÕŵÀµÂÔÔòÎÞÂÛÊÇ·ñ¾¹ýÕýʽ¹«²¼¶¼ÊÇÒ»¸öÉç»á·¨ÂɵÄÒ»²¿·Ö£¬ÕâͬÉç»áÉú»îÊÂʵÀíÂÛÏàµÖ´¥¡£¸üÎªÖØÒªµÄÊÇ£¬µÂÎֽ𷴶ԿɷÖÀëÐÔÀíÂÛ£¬ÒòΪËûµÄ¹ÛµãËÆºõ°µÊ¾×ÅijЩ¹æÔòµÄ±ØÈ»ÓÐЧÐÔÀ´×ÔÆäµÀµÂÄÚÈÝ¡£ÕýÊÇÕâÒ»¶Ô¿É·ÖÀëÀíÂ۵ķñ¶¨Ê¹µÃµÂÎÖ½ðÕ¾ÔÚÁË×ÔÈ»Ö÷ÒåÕßµÄÕóÓªÖС£
²Î¿¼ÎÄÏ×£º
Thomas Aquinas, On Law, Morality and Politics (Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Co., 1988)
John Austin, Lectures on Jurisprudence and the Philosophy of Positive Law (St. Clair Shores, MI: Scholarly Press, 1977)
------The Province of Jurisprudence Determined (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995)
Jeremy Bentham, A Fragment of Government (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988)
------Of Laws In General (London: Athlone Press, 1970)
------The Principles of Morals and Legislation (New York: Hafner Press, 1948)
Brian Bix, ¡°On Description and Legal Reasoning,¡± in Linda Meyer (ed.), Rules and Reasoning (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1999)
------Jurisprudence: Theory and Context (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1996)
------¡°Natural Law Theory,¡± in Dennis M. Patterson (ed.), A Companion to Philosophy of Law and Legal Theory (Cambridge: Blackwell Publishing Co., 1996)
William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Law of England (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1979)
Jules L. Coleman, ¡°On the Relationship Between Law and Morality,¡± Ratio Juris, vol. 2, no. 1 (1989), 66-78
------¡°Negative and Positive Positivism,¡± 11 Journal of Legal Studies 139 (1982)
Jules L. Coleman and Jeffrie Murphy, Philosophy of Law (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1990)
Ronald M. Dworkin, Law's Empire (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1986)
------Taking Rights Seriously (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1977)
John Finnis, Natural Law and Natural Rights (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1980)
------¡°The Truth in Legal Positivism,¡± in Robert P. George, The Autonomy of Law (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1996), 195-214
Lon L. Fuller, The Morality of Law, Revised Edition (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1964)
------¡°A Reply to Professors Cohen and Dworkin¡±, 10 Villanova Law Review 655 (1965), 657.
------¡°Positivism and Fidelity to Law--A Reply to Professor Hart,¡± 71 Harvard Law Review 630 (1958)
Klaus F¨¹?er, ¡°Farewell to ¡®Legal Positivism¡¯: The Separation Thesis Unravelling,¡± in George, The Autonomy of Law, 119-162
Robert P. George, ¡°Natural Law and Positive Law,¡± in George, The Autonomy of Law, 321-334
------Natural Law Theory: Contemporary Essays (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992)
H.L.A. Hart, The Concept of Law, Second Edition (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994)
------¡°Book Review of The Morality of Law¡± 78 Harvard Law Review 1281 (1965)
------Essays on Bentham (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1982)
------¡°Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals,¡± 71 Harvard Law Review 593 (1958)
Kenneth Einar Himma, ¡°Positivism, Naturalism, and the Obligation to Obey Law,¡± Southern Journal of Philosophy, vol. 36, no. 2 (Summer 1999)
------¡°Functionalism and Legal Theory: The Hart/Fuller Debate Revisited,¡± De Philosophia, vol. 14, no. 2 (Fall/Winter 1998)
J.L. Mackie, ¡°The Third Theory of Law,¡± Philosophy & Public Affairs, Vol. 7, No. 1 (Fall 1977)
Michael Moore, ¡°Law as a Functional Kind,¡± in George, Natural Law Theory, 188-242
Joseph Raz, The Authority of Law: Essays on Law and Morality (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979)
------¡°Authority, Law and Morality,¡± The Monist, vol. 68, 295-324
------¡°Legal Principles and the Limits of Law,¡± 81 Yale Law Review 823 (1972)
Geoffrey Sayre-McCord, ¡°The Many Moral Realisms,¡± in Sayre-McCord (ed.), Essays on Moral Realism, (Ithica: Cornell University Press, 1988)
A tendency of the temporary theory of natural law in U.S.
Kenneth Einar Himma Xu Shuang
(Southwest University of Political Science and Law, Chongqing 400031)
Abstract: The term¡°natural law¡±can be explicated and deduced under the ethical theory as well as the legal theory. According to natural law theorists, any opinion subscribing to law must has certain moral properties should belong to Overlap Thesis. Furthermore, Overlap Thesis, blended with the conceptual naturalism, may seem to be a number of different outlook that it can be interpreted. Based on thus, this article is just engaged in an elaborate research to the tendency of the temporary theory of natural law in U.S., especially for John Finnis, L.Fuller and Ronald Dworkin.
Key words: Overlap Thesis; conceptual jurisprudence; Neo-Naturalism; Procedural Naturalism; Third Theory of Law
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[1] Ëùν¡°½»µþÂÛ¡±£¨Overlap Thesis£©£¬ÊµÔòÊÇÑÐÌÖ·¨µÄ±¾ÖʺÍÌØÐÔµÄÒ»ÖÖÀíÂÛ¡£ÕâÖÖÀíÂÛ¹Ø×¢µÄ½¹µã£¬¼¯ÖÐÓÚijһ¹æÔòÒª³ÉÆäΪ·¨±ØÐë¾ß±¸µÄ¸÷ÖÖÌõ¼þ¡£°´½»µþÀíÂ۵Ĺ۵㣬·¨Ö®Îª¡°·¨¡±£¬±ØµÃÂú×ãµÀµÂÒªÇó£»»»¾ä»°Ëµ£¬½»µþÂÛÈÏΪ·¨¾ß±¸µÄµÀµÂÊôÐÔÕýÊÇ·¨×îÖØÒªµÄÌØÕ÷Ö®Ò»¡£¾ÙÀý¶øÑÔ£¬½»µþÀíÂÛÈÏΪ·¨Âɺ͵ÀµÂÖ®¼äµÄ¹ØÏµÕýÈçµ¥ÉíºÍδ»éµÄ¹ØÏµÒ»Ñù£¬Òª½âÊ͵¥Éí¾ÍÀë²»¿ªÎ´»éÕâÒ»¸ÅÄ¡ª¾¡¹Üδ»éÖ»Êǵ¥Éí״̬µÄÌØÕ÷Ö®Ò»¡£Í¬ÑùµÄµÀÀí£¬ÔÚ½»µþÂÛ¿´À´£¬²»½èÖúµÀµÂÖ÷ÕÅÒ²¾ÍÎÞ·¨²ûÃ÷·¨µÄÏà¹ØÀíÂÛ¡£
»ù±¾ÉÏ£¬ËùÓеÄ×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§Õß¶¼ÔÞͬ½»µþÀíÂÛ£¬µ«ËûÃǸ÷×ԵĹ۵ãÒ²ÓÐһЩϸ΢²îÒì¡£±ÈÈ磬¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼ÒÏàÐÅÿһ·¨Ìõ¶¼±ØÐë¾ß±¸µÀµÂÊôÐÔ£¬¶ø¸»ÀÕÔòÈÏΪ·¨ÂÉÌåϵ×÷Ϊһ¸öÕûÌåÂú×ãÏà¹ØµÄµÀµÂÒªÇó¾Í×ãÒÓ¡£ÓÖ±ÈÈ磬¹Åµä×ÔÈ»·¨Ñ§¼Ò¼á³ÖµÀµÂÊôÐÔÊÇ·¨µÄÒ»°ã¸ÅÄîµÄÓ¦ÓÐÖ®Ò⣬¶øÔÚ·ÆÄá˹¿´À´£¬ËùνµÀµÂÊôÐÔ½ö½öÊÇÔÚ·¨µÄ¡°ÀíÏë״̬¡±Ï¶øÑԵġ£¡ª¡ªÒëÕß×¢
[2] ͨ³£À´½²£¬ÎÒÃǶÔijһÑо¿¶ÔÏó±¾ÖÊ¡¢ÌØÕ÷µÄÃèÊö£¬Ò²±»ÊÓΪÊǶÔÕâÒ»¶ÔÏó¸ÅÄîµÄ½â˵¡£»»ÑÔÖ®£¬¸ø³öijһ¶ÔÏó±¾ÖÊ¡¢ÌØÕ÷µÄÏà¹ØÀíÂÛÒ²¾ÍÊǸø³öÁËÕâÒ»¶ÔÏóµÄ¸ÅÄî¡£Òò´Ë£¬Ëùν¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧʵ¼ÊÉϾÍÊÇÓйط¨¸ÅÄîµÄÒ»ÖÖÀíÂÛ·ÖÎö¡£¸ÅÄîÐÔ·¨ÕÜѧ´óÖÂÓÐÁ½´óÀà±ð£ºÒ»ÊÇÈÏͬ×ÔÈ»·¨ÀíÂÛ¶øÔ޳ɷ¨ºÍµÀµÂÖ®¼äµÄÁªÏµ£»¶þÊÇÇãÏòÓÚ·¨ÂÉʵ֤Ö÷Òå¶ø·ñ¶¨ÕâÒ»ÁªÏµ¡£¡ª¡ªÒëÕß×¢
[3] À׸ùËßÅÁ¶ûĬһ°¸µÄ°¸Çé´óÖÂÈçÏ£ºÄ³ÈËÊÇÆä׿¸¸ËùÁ¢ÒÅÖöÖ¸¶¨µÄ²Æ²ú¼Ì³ÐÈË£¬ËûΪÁ˼°ÔçµÃµ½Õâ±ÊÒŲú¶ø½«Æä׿¸¸É±ËÀ¡£·¨¹Ù±ØÐëÅж¨£¬ÔÚ´ËÇé¿öÏ£¬ÊÇ·ñÈÔÓ¦ÒÀÕռ̳з¨µÄ×ÖÃæ½âÊÍ£¬½«ÒŲúÅиøÉ±ÈËÕßËùÓС£¡ª¡ªÒëÕß×¢